4 ms·
I know there have been some reforms since 2015, though I haven't kept up with all the details. Isn't there a simple fix for this? Set per-company max percenta
by kelnos 8y ago
I know there have been some reforms since 2015, though I haven't kept up with all the details.
Isn't there a simple fix for this? Set per-company max percentages for H-1B visa holders. So if it's 15%, and you have 100 employees, only 15 of them can be H-1Bs. I imagine there are probably ways to game this as well, but I'd think it'd be easier to figure out when that gaming is occurring, and shut it down.
Or is there just no political will to fix it?
- mc32 8y agoYou could also tax the companies per H-1B [25% -50% of salary?] and dedicate that money to develop native talent [Get kids into STEM starting from K, and train or offer education to candidates wanting to transition into new fields]. If a company really needs these workers, they’ll gladly pay the premium and the local pool of workers or future workers get support to get into that field and reduce the need to import labor. Allow H-1Bs a free transition to alternate co. to ensure commensurate wages.
- kelnos 8y agoAn interesting idea, but in the end probably not something politicians would like. (What does "money to develop native talent" go to, anyway?) Regardless, large companies are experts at shuffling profits around to avoid paying taxes, so I doubt this would curb the abuses. The application process (fees to the government plus paying lawyers) already costs a decent amount, so perhaps just raising those fees would help? The outsourcing companies have pretty deep pockets, though, so in the end that would just hurt smaller shops that actually have a need for H-1B workers. I think per-company caps are the way to go. They don't hurt the companies, and they should actually solve the problem. An alternative might be to just outlaw these sorts of outsourcing firms. Stipulate that H-1B visa holders must be employed by the company where they actually work (no contracting arrangements), and the sponsor of the H-1B can't be a third-party company.
- belltaco 8y agoThere is already such a fee included in H1B application fees that has raised billions for developing native talent.
- munk-a 8y agoYes, there is a trivial fix for this: Remove H-1B visas entirely. H-1B visas lower employee power in the hiring arrangement, forcing potential candidates to accept lower wages by allowing companies to retain existing H-1B workers indefinitely without wage adjustments. Lowering the ability for a class of workers to advocate for themselves lowers the ability for all workers in that field to advocate for themselves by removing a subset of those workers' bargaining power. In all honesty, H-1B visas mostly seem to fit into society as a way to outsource without looking like you're doing so - I'd rather companies outsource as they desire (and feel the penalties of doing so) or be forced to hire from a pool of candidates who were able to legally immigrate into the US. If the pool of candidates available in the US is too low then we should relax quota laws and let more people immigrate. Done. And there is no political will because a lot of companies make tons of money off of exploiting workers who have two options (1) continue working for the company and accrue no or very few benefits over time (2) quit and be deported. Giving your employees a choice like that makes all the worst people in management salivate... thus no one lobbies to remove H-1B visas, many people lobby to maintain or expand this "source of skilled labour" and politicians see no reason to take a stand on an issue that gets very little time in the spotlight and would cost them big in terms of donations.
- euos 8y agoH1 does not lower employee power. I came on H1, got laid off within one year and then had to change companies again in 6 months. I could do it just fine.
- longerthoughts 8y agoTo combat the case presented in the article, I think you'd also need to cap applications at a relatively low percentage of workforce to prevent the flood effect rather than just capping the number of H-1B holders.
- euos 8y agoStaffing companies should not be able to bring people. Only direct hires. This will fix H1 and will not require increasing cap and such.
- MisterBastahrd 8y agoThere's a simpler fix. Companies have gotten away for decades by posting ridiculous job qualifications and then turning around and claiming that since there is no American they can find who is qualified to do the job, that they need to hire cheap foreign talent. I ran into that over and over again as a technical recruiter who would find teams of American citizens and green card holders suddenly displaced by H1s at half their rates. In these instances, companies should pay 150% of the going market compensation to the H1 employee for the position and an additional 50% to a fund which provides training to local job candidates to create future competition for the position.
- Johnny555 8y agoIf the goal is to keep US employers competitive by letting them hire the best and brightest workers from around the world, doubling employee compensation costs is probably not going to achieve that - the companies will just open foreign offices. Which is already happening due to uncertainty of the entire program, my company shifted from opening a USA branch office to opening an european office to make it easier to hire european workers. And it's not like we're using H1-B's as cheap labor, all of our H1-B's are PhD's (well, maybe a few Master's degrees in the mix that have significant experience), and are well compensated. We have a strong USA college recruitment program too.