4 ms·
So is Earnest Capital more of a charity than a profit making enterprise? I really like what you are doing, serving the vast majority of businesses that don't w
by jedberg 8y ago
So is Earnest Capital more of a charity than a profit making enterprise? I really like what you are doing, serving the vast majority of businesses that don't want to be hyper growth.
But for the math to work out, with a 3x cap on earnings, you need 33% of the businesses to be successful just to get your money back. At 5x you still need 20%. And that is over however long it takes for those companies to reach payback, which could be measured in decades for some of the companies.
I think it's really altruistic, but I'm not sure how big this market segment could actually get.
- berberous 8y agoWebsite also says: "In most cases, we’ll agree on a long-term residual stake for Earnest if you ever sell the company or raise more financing."
- fragsworth 8y agoThey don't explain it, but it sounds like the whole deal is effectively seed financing where they eventually get a 9.5% stake, but also with a 3-5x loan interest payment once you make money (which they're framing as "Shared Earnings"). And they're trying to hide the 9.5% part.
- tylertringas 8y agoHiding? https://earnestcapital.com/shared-earnings-agreement-digging-into-the-numbers/ https://earnestcapital.com/shared-earnings-agreement-digging...
- tfehring 8y agoI'm not OP, but it's worth mentioning that Earnest starts to recoup its investment as soon as founders take a salary. Its calculator [0] shows a percentage of 30% by default - if that's accurate, for the 67%-80% of companies that fail, Earnest would still recoup 30% of its investment (ignoring other expenses and time value of money) even if those companies never saw a penny of revenue. Also, they list a starting point of $2k-$5k in MRR, and on a $150k investment with a 30% split, they break even as soon as the founder(s) have taken $350k in total salary (again ignoring time value of money), including any salary paid out of the original $150k investment. I don't want to trivialize the process of scaling a startup beyond $2k-$5k of MRR, but I bet more than 20% of companies with $2k-$5k of MRR are capable of reaching that point. [0] https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1h_L7oa3rbV8P-ZnMM-l1fY5zc97GetYkRjQ_zCi6by4 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1h_L7oa3rbV8P-ZnMM-l1... edited for clarity
- mbesto 8y ago> Earnest would still recoup 30% of its investment (ignoring other expenses and time value of money) even if those companies never saw a penny of revenue. How so? Who's paying that 30% if you have zero revenue?...did you mean "if those companies never saw a penny of profit"?
- tfehring 8y agoBased on my reading of their terms, it seems like they get back 30% of their own investment if the rest is entirely used to pay founders' salaries. So on a $150k investment, they have potential upside of $300k to $600k after they recoup their initial investment, while they can lose at most ~$105k when investing in businesses that have low expenses outside of founders' salaries.
- tylertringas 8y agoWe also have a residual, uncapped, % option if the founder ever sells the business. This keeps us aligned with the founders to keep helping them grow the value of the business for the long-term even after the Return Cap is paid back. > I'm not sure how big this market segment could actually get. Keep following along and see :)
- mbesto 8y ago> We also have a residual, uncapped, % option if the founder ever sells the business. What exactly is a "residual stake"? In your spreadsheet this is set as 9.5%...where did that come from? Is this is a stock option, convertible note, or equity position?
- fragsworth 8y agoIt sounds to me like a critically important part of their model that they don't want you to understand or think about. There's nothing about it on their site from what I saw.
- tylertringas 8y agoThe residual stake is a factor of the investment amount, the Valuation Cap (negotiated at time of investment) and the terms of a sale. Note by "stake" we just mean an option to participate in a sale. You can run the business profitably forever without paying us a penny. There is a screencast here going over every term and a spreadsheet anybody can use to run the numbers. Not hiding anything :) https://earnestcapital.com/shared-earnings-agreement-digging-into-the-numbers/ https://earnestcapital.com/shared-earnings-agreement-digging...
- mbesto 8y ago> we just mean an option to participate in a sale By what instrument though? Are you offering a stock option at a strike price? Is it equity at a priced round? Or is a convertible note? Other? You can just say "if you sell we have the option to take a %"...
- tylertringas 8y agoI think it means we're on to something if we have folks in this thread arguing from boths sides that we're so founder friendly we'll never turn a profit AND that our terms are "predatory" and worse than a bank loan :) The secret is there's a huge opportunity in between and tons of amazing founders and businesses we're excited to back.