4 ms·
To quote someone else on HN: > Why is it desirable to transfer money from job-producing companies and investors to the government? The government is a money p
by exabrial 8y ago
To quote someone else on HN:
> Why is it desirable to transfer money from job-producing companies and investors to the government?
The government is a money pit. We're long past "essential services". I'm happy to see companies paying 0 tax into the waste pit.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- octonion 8y agoHow about essential services like affordable healthcare, education, job training, housing and transportation? Every other major country has no trouble providing these, only the US.
- spectrum1234 8y agoOnce healthcare and education costs (and probably housing and transportation) aren't increasing way faster than inflation, sure.
- komali2 8y agoDoesn't it make sense for costs to go up as the population increases?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 8y agoThey're increasing a lot faster where healthcare isn't socialised...
- 2019ideas 8y agoLook at this list of top lobbyists. Oddly they correspond closely with everything you listed. Our government is very active in these. They just arent doing a great job. https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?indexType=s https://www.opensecrets.org/lobby/top.php?indexType=s >Healthcare The government has been active in regulating healthcare for 30 years. Oddly during that time Physicians became 300k/yr earners, Pharmacists became 6 figure earners. Hospitals, Pharma and everyone between are growing. >Education, job training Highly funded k12 education, subsidized loans for college >housing Blaming real estate laws for this, but Im mostly out of the loop. Real estate is a top lobby >Transportation Maybe, but I feel like this could be bad for the environment.
- umanwizard 8y agoPer capita, the US spends more public money on education than other developed countries, and about the same on healthcare (this is only counting public money, so the US is spending the same amount for much lower coverage). If you think we should be spending even more, can you give numbers? How much, in your opinion should be budgeted per citizen for healthcare and education? It seems clear to me that lack of money isn't the problem.
- docker_up 8y agoI would love it if the government would spend money on that. Instead they spend money on wars, the military, corn subsidies, their own pensions, etc. Until they fix their SPENDING problem, I don't trust them with my tax money.
- omegaworks 8y agoIn so many ways, without the services provided by the government, Amazon would cease to function. Just think for one moment longer about the logistical complexities involved in getting you a package. You need a unique address identifier, streets that are paved, a global trade network that won't be pilfered by pirates, currency with value and neighbors with stable enough incomes that they don't see the postman and take your package for themselves. Libertarianism is a pipe dream. Your desire for our transition to a failed state would be the undoing of the institutions that make your cushy life possible.
- umanwizard 8y agoWhat's more, a huge chunk of the federal government's budget is dedicated to murdering people in foreign countries.
- komali2 8y agoCome on. Who guarantees amazon isn't immediately overwhelmed with ten thousand copycat sites with similar URLs? Who built the roads upon which employees drive to get to HQ? Upon which delivery drivers drive to get packages to customers? Who ensures Amazon doesn't need someone riding shotgun, with a shotgun, with every delivery driver? I'm not even scraping the surface here. Libertarianism, I presume? The free market would have done a better job at building a sovereign system in which Amazon could thrive?
- umanwizard 8y agoOut of your points, only the first (trademark litigation) is handled at the federal level, and extremely inefficiently at that. Roads and police are (mostly, with some exceptions) controlled by the states.
- komali2 8y agoWhich are governments, which levy taxes...
- umanwizard 8y agoThe thread is about how much federal income tax Amazon paid.
- komali2 8y agoI don't follow. The state exists only as an aspect of the federal government. If the federal government didn't exist, the state would just have its own taxes to fund the education system, judicial system, military, etc.
- umanwizard 8y agoYes that's true, but there is no a priori reason to assume that they would be as outrageously wasteful and inefficient as the US federal government, which: (1) spends about as much per capita on healthcare as other OECD countries, with dramatically worse coverage, (2) spends about 10x the world average on military, per capita, (3) has a political system that is set up to make meaningful reform almost impossible, and so on...