4 ms·
The example you gave is a diversity of skills, and that diversity of skills was actually a requirement for your business. If the inclusion of individuals posses
by ralusek 8y ago
The example you gave is a diversity of skills, and that diversity of skills was actually a requirement for your business. If the inclusion of individuals possessing those additional skills (ability to speak Spanish, ability to network effectively in a given foreign country/culture) happens to map on to a racial or ethnic diversity, great, but that's not what's being advocated for here.
This also brings up an interesting point of contention. The diversity dance has 2 arguments at odds with themselves.
Claim 1: All populations of people are inherently equivalent and should therefore have proportional representations in all things.
Claim 2: Diversity is a boon because populations are inherently unique and provide a unique set of characteristics to the table.
Pick one. You cannot make both of those claims simultaneously.
You are advocating in favor of Claim 2, which is fine, but what if the position in question doesn't actually benefit from a diverse set of skills? What if it's a low level circuit designer that tends to favor a particular skillset and personality type? Is it not possible that attributes more commonly represented in a certain population might be overrepresented in sectors that require those characteristics?
In contrast, if you advocate instead for Claim 1, then there should be no discernible advantage to diverse hiring, it's just that a failure to do so would be indicative of bias.
- dontreact 8y agoI don't know anyone who believes in Claim 1 as you've presented it. There is an alternate version that I do believe "All populations of people are inherently valuable and therefore should not be left behind by advancements in technology" The examples I gave were both cases where it was not obvious at all to predict that the skills would be needed. For example, while the low level circuit designer probably won't benefit from cultural and racial awareness, he may not always be a low level circuit designer in the company. He may rise in the company and start making decisions about how/where/which circuits are built. And at some point having cultural and racial awareness would be a benefit.
- ralusek 8y agoAll populations are inherently valuable, to whom? Every business values every population intrinsically? How do you decide how valuable they are? Do you need to hire as many Maori from New Zealand and as many Inuit from Alaska as their world populations would dictate, or are their intrinsic values allowed to differ in any capacity?
- dontreact 8y agoLet me rephrase Individuals are valuable regardless of group memberships. Therefore it makes sense to avoid leaving large groups of people behind, regardless of which group it is.