5 ms·
Either approach, whether it recaptures the oxidizer or fuel rich preburner exhaust, is clearly an improvement over dumping everything overboard. But neither is
by twic 8y ago
Either approach, whether it recaptures the oxidizer or fuel rich preburner exhaust, is clearly an improvement over dumping everything overboard. But neither is an ideal solution as there’s still potentially combustible products being wasted.
Are there? Here's a diagram of the RD-180, which uses an oxygen-rich preburner:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-180#/media/File:Rd180schematic.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-180#/media/File:Rd180schema...
Where is anything escaping other than through the combustion chamber?
- CarVac 8y agoThere's no wasted propellant with normal staged combustion. But full flow staged combustion lets you fully vaporize both propellants before they mix, leading to more optimal burning.
- avmich 8y agoMore importantly, supply more power to the pumps thus allowing higher pressure in the chamber, and so higher Isp.
- ceejayoz 8y agoScroll one paragraph down from that quote and the RD-180's approach is mentioned. > In the 1950’s, Soviet scientists came up with something of a compromise. Instead of using a fuel-rich mixture in the preburner which produced an exhaust that couldn’t be safely recirculated into the engine, they experimented with running the preburner oxygen-rich. > Eventually the Soviets mastered the metallurgy required to build the turbine and developed several engines that operated on the oxygen-rich preburner concept. The exhaust was piped into the engine’s combustion chamber and recovered at least some of the propellants which would otherwise have been dumped overboard. The modern day Russian RD-180 engine, currently in use by the American Atlas V, is a continuation of this technology.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hoorayimhelping 8y agoThe diagram doesn't show that the fuel used in the preburner is combusted less efficiently than the fuel used in the main combustion chamber. It comes out through the nozzle, but isn't fully combusted (it comes out as liquid, while the main fuels are gasses) and so is wasted energy. From what I understand, the fuel and oxidizer that has been through the preburners to spin the turbines is basically fungible with fuel and oxidizer that is used in the combustion chamber.
- CarVac 8y agoI'm not sure where you're getting that. If it's incompletely burned in the preburner, it gets completely burned in the combustion chamber. And even if that were true that combustion happening in the preburner was wasted, then full-flow staged combustion would be equally bad because it still has preburners.