4 ms·
Exactly. The kind of millionaire you don’t want is thd one who hides money under the mattress. Those who invest or conspicuously splurge are a boon to the eco
by mc32 8y ago
Exactly. The kind of millionaire you don’t want is thd one who hides money under the mattress.
Those who invest or conspicuously splurge are a boon to the economy and to workers.
- greeneggs 8y agoThis is wrong economically. Conspicuously splurging is just a waste of resources. If a wealthy person and all her descendants save their money forever, then there's no harm to the economy. The money is just numbers in a computer, nothing concrete. (Politically, it could be dangerous, since there is always the threat that they could spend it.) If she spends it digging holes, on the other hand, then that's wasting real resources. It employs people, yes, but in a pointless task. Their labor could have been better deployed. There's obviously a continuum, but $100 million yachts are probably closer to the digging-holes side of the continuum. (But maybe not. For example, spending $10 million on a painting for that yacht has very little real effect, since aside from the purchase transfer overhead, it is mostly moving numbers from one bank account to another.)
- covercash 8y agoI imagine some of the r&d (tech, materials, manufacturing processes) leads to improvements in areas that less wealthy people benefit from.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- macspoofing 8y agoAnd how do you know what the correct usage of resources is? This is why communism _always_ fails. Every attempt at a top-down control of the entire economy will lead to failure. The economy is too complicated and chaotic for that to ever work.
- jordanbeiber 8y agoI see this a lot — the jump straight to ”communism”, and it’s tiresome. I believe in this day and age we know a lot of things we didnt’t at the start of industrialization. As soon as someone starts talking about keeping mindful about consumption they somehow end up being supportive of full blown communism. Looking at the state of our earth you could easily say that capitalism doesn’t work, at all. It’s more nuanced than that though.
- Pristina 8y ago> capitalism doesn’t work, at all. i look at north korea then i look at south korea. if capitalism doesn't work, at all, then communism must negatively work.
- jordanbeiber 8y agoQuestioning the end result of capitalism is obviously touchy for many... My comment was simply that you can question the state of capitalism in the world today without suggesting that communism should take it’s place. P.s Also, have a talk to the insects, polar bears, cheetahs (only 7000 of them beauties left), etc. Out of whack and out of balance.
- mc32 8y agoI would agree that communism is better at regulating population than other forms of government. And since population pressure is the main driver behind incursion into wildernesses, I’d agree communism would handle over pop more “efficiently” but not morally better. On the other hand communism typically suffered from stunted innovation, outside of targeted areas, so they probably would be worse off, if they didn’t import tech from non communist states.
- jordanbeiber 8y agoI kind of agree with what you’re saying, but it still lacks a lot of nuance. Most good stuff arises from public funded research imo. How and why? Because it’s down to individuals that are allowed to do their thing. This gets stiffled in a short term, for profit organization. What we’re left with is often conservatism. Too many big orgs with big money simply want to keep things as they are, and it’s clear (or should be to everyone) that this is not wanted or sustainable. Regarding man earth balance it’s currently down to over consumtion by us in the west. As your average Swede I consume approximately 4 earths worth of resources. We either changes this behaviour volontarily or bad things will happen eventually. There’s a lot of power in those piles of cash though so anyone that want’s to change anything is in for a tough fight. Also, morality... you probably consume stuff originating from sweat shops and child labour. We’ll it’s not our children! Lot of high horses in the ”west” unfortunateley.
- Pristina 8y agothe entirely of what you are saying is wrong economically. all forms of economic transaction involves transferring money from one account to another. conspicuous splurging is a waste not in itself, but because of the opportunity cost of instead spending that money on capital investment, which will lead to higher production and consumption in the future for more people. if a rich person has extra money, he can use it to pleasure himself, or he can spend it on investment, hoping to make even more money. if he were to buy machinery for example, that would mean higher production and lower price, and many people will benefit from that. the aggregate benefit is higher in the long term. but the goal of an economy is to allow as much conspicuously splurging as possible over the longest time possible. it is clearly utopic to have a society with such surpluses that everybody can own 10 space yachts, endless supply of the best food etc.