2 ms·
Even if a primary research study (such as the one mentioned in the link submitted here) is conducted without deliberate fraud, it may not be meaningful and may
by tokenadult 16y ago
Even if a primary research study (such as the one mentioned in the link submitted here) is conducted without deliberate fraud, it may not be meaningful and may not even be true.
http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html
To be convinced that the headline statement "US Scientists Significantly More Likely to Publish Fake Research" is true, I would go through Peter Norvig's checklist above, and see how many methodological issues may have been missed by the reported study. Then I would wait for a follow-up study by an independent researcher, preferably with different methodology and definitely based on a different data set. Right now, I have no idea whether or not there are national differences in rates of publication of fake research.