2 ms·
In fairness, at my company we use a custom dialect of CL which does not have a type system, so I may not have enough perspective to make broad statements about
by brundolf 8y ago
In fairness, at my company we use a custom dialect of CL which does not have a type system, so I may not have enough perspective to make broad statements about the Lisp community. Though, intuitively, I'd think that in a language all about dynamic data structures and self-modifying code, static analysis would be really hard. But I may just be ignorant in this area.
- taeric 8y agoI can't claim a lack of ignorance in this area. It is always baffling when you see just what some of the older lisp machines were capable of. Too many posts reduce this to some sort of "magic of lisp" message. Which is certainly fun, in many ways. However, I think most of it is just a lot of hard work that was done by folks. Much of which will never be considered by the rest of us, almost solely on lack of information. So, yes, I imagine in many ways it is harder. Doesn't make it impossible, though. And indeed, most type checking can be almost trivially done. As an example, typechecking the arguments to a format command. Trivially easy in most invocations. Only when people do build up dynamic programs is this hard. Thing is, those programs are hard to even think of, so most of us don't write them.