4 ms·
> it's a good first step No, it isn't; it's whatever the locality decides is a good setpoint for a revenue source. Most "speed limits" have nothing to do with
by pdonis 8y ago
> it's a good first step
No, it isn't; it's whatever the locality decides is a good setpoint for a revenue source. Most "speed limits" have nothing to do with safety.
Even on interstate highways, where the "revenue source" motivation is the least, many speed limits are still too low given the improvements in vehicle handling and performance since the 55 mph rule was arbitrarily selected in the early 1970s. Of course, that argument assumes that 55 mph was reasonable for early 1970s cars--but if the primary purpose is safety, well, there are still traffic deaths at the current speed limits, so why not lower them further? Why not stop people from driving at all, if nothing short of that will eliminate traffic deaths?
That kind of argument leads down a rabbit hole. I think a much better way of viewing things, as I said in another comment upthread, is in terms of a principal-agent problem. If you are driving yourself (or flying yourself, for that matter), you can make your own judgments about safety (and take the consequences). But if you are flying (or driving) other people for money, then you have to abide by an explicit set of standards because it's no longer just you who takes the consequences if you make an error of judgment. And the more people who are endangered if you make an error, the more stringent the standards should be.
- Johnny555 8y agoWhen it's enforced by cars, it's no longer a revenue source.
- pdonis 8y agoNo, just an even worse power put in the hands of governments. Try this thought experiment: suppose we are at some point in the future, when self-driving cars are ubiquitous and are proven to be safer than human-driven cars. Do you want governments to have the ability to force your self-driving car to do something based on some arbitrary setting of a limit, controlled by government bureaucrats? Or do you want to have control over what algorithms your self-driving car runs and what actions it takes if it detects a problem?
- Johnny555 8y agoI want everyone's cars to follow the same rules, I don't want individual people modding their cars to obey only the laws they like or to behave differently than everyone else's cars.
- pdonis 8y ago> I want everyone's cars to follow the same rules How would the rules be determined? > I don't want individual people modding their cars to obey only the laws they like or to behave differently than everyone else's cars. So basically, you don't trust the judgment of individual people. But you trust the judgment of a government that is composed of individual people?
- Johnny555 8y agoHow would the rules be determined? USDOT/FHWA So basically, you don't trust the judgment of individual people. But you trust the judgment of a government that is composed of individual people? Yes.
- pdonis 8y agoOk, then I guess we'll just have to disagree.
- Johnny555 8y agoyeah, I think it's the difference in opinion between those that see cars only as transportation, and those that see driving as an experience itself. I'm happy to give up control of driving if it means car travel is safer and more convenient, just like I'm happy to get on a train, bus, or airplane and let someone else drive (under high regulation - I don't want my pilot to decide on his own that ATC is being ridiculously conservative and there's plenty of room for him to land between two A380's).
- Spooky23 8y ago
- ceejayoz 8y agoSeems like your objection would be solved by the proposal. Towns would no longer have this bullshit revenue source, and might actually set the limits to a reasonable level instead of one intended to make you screw up.
- pdonis 8y ago> Seems like your objection would be solved by the proposal. No, it wouldn't. In fact the proposal would make things worse, because it would give an even greater level of control to governments than they have now. Right now, all they can do is give me a ticket if I'm speeding. Under this proposal, they would be able to remove control of my car from me altogether based on some arbitrary limit. That is thousands of disasters waiting to happen. > Towns would no longer have this bullshit revenue source, and might actually set the limits to a reasonable level instead of one intended to make you screw up. You have much more faith than I do in the ability of the government to know better what is reasonable and prudent under a given set of conditions than the person actually driving the car in those conditions. Not to mention their ability to ensure a safe implementation of the actual mechanics of the proposal.
- ceejayoz 8y agoI have a lot more faith in road engineers than individual drivers on determining safe limits. Untrained individuals are pretty crap at this, especially in areas they're unfamiliar with - an out-of-town visitor can hardly know that there's a low-visibility hairpin turn coming up. Removing the perverse revenue incentives of artificially low limits seems like a good step.
- pdonis 8y ago> I have a lot more faith in road engineers than individual drivers on determining safe limits. The road engineers aren't there. The driver is. Also, the road engineers suffer no consequences if the limits are wrong. > Untrained individuals are pretty crap at this Perhaps. If so, I think it's because individuals have no voice in determining the limits, and they know the limits are bogus anyway, so they don't view exceeding them as an error, they just view it as a game they're playing vs. the police. In other words, since there is no reward for exercising better individual judgment, and the penalties are unrelated to the quality of an individual's judgment, there is no incentive for individuals to develop better judgment. > an out-of-town visitor can hardly know that there's a low-visibility hairpin turn coming up. That's what warning signs are for. There's no need for it to be a speed limit; just a "caution, hairpin turn" sign is enough. > Removing the perverse revenue incentives of artificially low limits seems like a good step. The way to remove those incentives is to stop allowing governments to penalize people who have caused no harm. Sure, put up a sign that says that, according to our best qualified road engineers, the maximum safe speed for this road is x. (For bonus points, make the sign programmable so the posted limit can vary with weather conditions, day vs. night, etc.) But don't allow the government to give me a ticket and make me pay a fine just because I exceed speed x. If I cause an accident and it's found that I exceeded speed x, then the government can penalize me--but penalize me because I caused harm (and, if you like, tack on an extra penalty because I ignored the advisory sign and my error of judgment contributed to the harm).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 8y ago> since the 55 mph rule was arbitrarily selected in the early 1970s It was selected in 1974 in response to the 1973 oil crisis in the hope of reducing oil consumption. 55 was intended as a speed that delivers best mpg for typical 1970s vehicles.
- Aloha 8y agoMost freeways had a design speed of 75, for vehicles manufactured in the year they were designed.