4 ms·
> Really? We're there now? It's become Apple's "responsibility" to police every last corner of iOS? I find it disgusting, but really Apple is the only one to b
by freedomben 8y ago
> Really? We're there now? It's become Apple's "responsibility" to police every last corner of iOS?
I find it disgusting, but really Apple is the only one to blame for that when they started aggressively policing and removing apps, and then marketing to customers based on that. I've heard people on HN state ad nauseam that they love that Apple does this, and that it's one of the reasons they live in the Apple ecosystem. They want to be protected from running apps that might do something objectionable (according to Apple's standard), and are absolutely willing to trade their freedom for some security.
I obviously don't agree with this at all (I refer you to Cory Doctorow's War on General Purpose Computing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI ) but it is a position I can understand.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoApple could have it both ways. Keep the App Store, but make sideloading possible—without this stupid certificate program. Make it semi-difficult: maybe users have to tap their version number twenty times or something. Just keep the avenue open. It does not harm your security if other people are able to sideload apps. Apple should just flip the damn switch.
- MaxBarraclough 8y agoI figure part of it is the way malware plays out in PR terms. The headlines would read iOS malware steals private data, not Moron sideloads malware onto iPhone, subverting the appstore they already paid to curate. Personal responsibility doesn't play much of a role in the media response to these incidents, so Apple are well motivated to prevent customers getting root access to their own devices. (To say nothing of the lucrative appstore business model.) I recall sideloaded Android malware getting this kind of silly response. Hardly Google's fault if you go out of your way to compromise your device, but it can still make for bad publicity. As it is, the only 'open avenue' on iPhone is to use the browser.
- Wowfunhappy 8y agoYou're not wrong, but it doesn't excuse Apple's actions. Mac OS seems to get along well enough, as does Android despite some occasional bumps in the road. (The Android ecosystem has legitimate security issues regarding un-updatable devices, but that's not relevant here.) We should all be pushing Apple to make their products more open, not asking them for be more stringent. I really do think that if public sentiment shifted in just the right way, we could see Apple allow sideloading. Steve Jobs is gone, and Apple is pushing the iPad as both a PC replacement and a STEM education device. Both efforts are hampered by an inability to run custom apps. This TechCrunch article really bothers me. They are a tech-specific site, and should not be running the type of headlines you describe. The fact that companies break Apple's guidelines is newsworthy and fine to report on, but if Apple deserves any blame here it should be for making this crap necessary in the first place.
- threeseed 8y agoI am one of those people that buy into the Apple way. That doesn't mean I expect them to review every single internal enterprise app that every company on the planet builds. I simply expect them to police the App Store so I am not wasting my money or destroying my phone/tablet.
- TorKlingberg 8y agoIndeed. What you position yourself as the gatekeeper, you will be held responsible for what gets through the gate. Including things you weren't originally planning to block. Anyone who wants to stop anything will come to you, and you brought it on yourself.
- apostacy 8y agoOn the one hand, this "journalism" really is disgusting. It is calling for unreasonable censorship. Censoring internal enterprise apps makes as much sense as expecting Apple to police pictures users take with their iPhones. But on the other hand, Apple really should own their censorship. They decided to take responsibility stuff like this, so they really should be held responsible.