3 ms·
> I'm pretty sure we've managed to colonize a tract of uninhabited land at least a couple of times throughout history. Without a connection to existing civiliz
by lisper 8y ago
> I'm pretty sure we've managed to colonize a tract of uninhabited land at least a couple of times throughout history.
Without a connection to existing civilization, and without a source of easily accessible water provided by nature? No, we have never done that.
- dwild 8y agoWhat about the ISS? The water they consume is recycled and is clearly not provided by nature.
- lisper 8y agoThe ISS is very closely connected to civilization. It has real-time comms, and in an emergency a spacecraft can reach it in about six hours, or return an astronaut back to earth in less time than that. The longest it has ever gone between resupply missions is four months. The shortest time between resupply missions to Mars is two years.
- kakarot 8y ago> The shortest time between resupply missions to Mars is two years. You aren't going to be sending only one ship at a time. You will be staggering shipments, with 3-4 ships in transit at a time. You could make the time between resupplies as short as you want.
- jfoutz 8y agoResupply isn’t quite the right word. If I break the X, i have to fix it myself or wait 2 years.
- lisper 8y agoYou don't understand the orbital mechanics of getting to Mars. Getting to Mars only takes eight months, but you have to launch when Earth and Mars are in a particular configuration relative to each other, and that configuration only happens every two (Earth) years. You can launch as many ships as you like during those windows, but you can't stagger them.
- craftyguy 8y agoOnly if you want them to take no more than 18 months to arrive.. You can most definitely stagger supply ships and launch them at any time, it's just that some will take a bit longer than others to arrive and their various transit times can be taken into account to have them arrive in a staggered fashion.
- lisper 8y agoWell, sure, but how does that help? It's no different than having them arrive all at once and just waiting to open them. Whether they sit around on Mars or sit around in space doesn't matter.
- craftyguy 8y ago> Well, sure, but how does that help? It enables a continuous supply, without having to try to plan everything to happen all at once during a short launch window/timeframe > You can launch as many ships as you like during those windows, but you can't stagger them. Well, you don't have to only launch "during those windows". I'm no logistic genius, but it seems like it would be easier/more cost effective to loft resources towards Mars at intervals that don't depend on a relatively short event that occurs every ~18 months. Try collecting all of the things you need to go camping 30 minutes beforehand, vs over the period of a week/month before you go. Yea, not very effective.. ? Your comment I replied to above seems to be overly aggressive (that doesn't belong here): > You don't understand the orbital mechanics of getting to Mars. I'm quite sure there are lots of things you (or I) don't understand. Try being more constructive next time.
- lisper 8y ago> It enables a continuous supply No, it doesn't, as I explained in the GP comment. > I'm no logistic genius Yes, that's pretty clear. > Try being more constructive next time. Try being a little more appreciative when someone offers you their expertise for free [1]. And consider the possibility that /u/kakarot doesn't need you to be their white knight. Just FYI, I used to be a Principal Scientist at NASA where I worked on, among other things, the R&D program that led up to the Mars Pathfinder mission. So while I never designed orbital trajectories myself, I spent years hanging out with the people who did it for a living. Yes, there are a lot of things I don't understand, but the fundamental difficulties of shipping stuff to Mars are not among them. --- [1] OK, it's not quite free. The price is putting up with the fact that I'm a curmudgeon. Some people think that's a fair deal. If you don't, well, no one is putting a gun to your head and forcing you to engage with me.
- imgabe 8y ago> Without a connection to existing civilization, and without a source of easily accessible water provided by nature? No, we have never done that. Civilization had to start somewhere. At some point humans started a civilization without any connection to an existing civilization. In all likelihood, several times in different places on Earth. And on Mars that would not be "without a connection to an existing civilization" They would absolutely be bringing equipment and supplies from Earth and have a communication link. Easily accessible water is a different story, but that's just a technological problem.
- Retra 8y agoCivilization has only ever started in highly fertile ecosystems. It has never started in a place that basic plant life can't even survive.
- imgabe 8y agoWell I guess we're lucky there have been quite a few advances in helping plant and other forms of life survive in the past 200,000 years so. It's not like we're dropping a bunch of naked humans on the surface of Mars and expecting them to live off the land.
- Retra 8y agoMars is a gigantic frigid rock. You can't eat it, you can't breathe it, and you can't touch it. If you go to mars, you're going to be living in a bubble and it hardly even matters whether you're on Mars at that point (aside from being close enough to study it.) You could just as well colonize the bottom of the ocean or Antarctica, and there's plenty of value in doing those things because the rewards from the efforts could easily be transported back to normal society. And if you get sick or injured, you can still survive rather than casting your valuable experience into the void. If the advances you speak of can't help you survive in Earth's mildly hostile uninhabited environments, then you can't expect them to work on Mars.
- 8y ago