7 ms·
One indication that no one is even remotely ready to think seriously about colonizing Mars (including Space X): There are vast tracts of uninhabited land on ea
by lisper 8y ago
One indication that no one is even remotely ready to think seriously about colonizing Mars (including Space X): There are vast tracts of uninhabited land on earth, notably in the American West. Colonizing those would be vastly easier than colonizing Mars, and yet no one is even talking about that. A self-sustaining colony in the middle of the Nevada desert that was able to get by with no outside help for a few years would be about 1% as hard as colonizing Mars, and yet no one has done it, and no one AFAIK is planning to do it. This to me is the smoking gun that no one is really taking Mars colonization seriously. Everyone is caught up in the sexiness and glamour and no one wants to get down in the dirt and solve the really hard problems of how humans are actually going to survive when they are totally isolated from civilization for years.
Yes, I know about the HI-SEAS project. That was not isolated nor self-sustaining, and it only lasted 8 months.
https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/06/mars-simulation-hi-seas-nasa-hawaii/553532/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/06/mars-sim...
That's actually not even the sort of thing I'm talking about. Forget simulating Mars. I want to see someone just colonize an uninhabited part of Earth without relying on help from the outside without any other constraints. Until we can do that, Mars is hopeless.
- woah 8y agoUmmmm... how do you think that things were hundreds or thousands of years ago?
- Retra 8y agoIt's not clear what you're trying to say. All human colonization to date has been dependent upon fertile lands or extensive outside support. If we want to colonize Mars, we should prove we can survive without these things, and since nobody has done that on Earth, why should anybody they think it can be done on another planet?
- lisper 8y agoIn the Nevada desert? Pretty much the same as they are today: uninhabited.
- kakarot 8y agoI'm pretty sure we've managed to colonize a tract of uninhabited land at least a couple of times throughout history. Maybe we could better spend our time working on the things we haven't figured out.
- lisper 8y ago> I'm pretty sure we've managed to colonize a tract of uninhabited land at least a couple of times throughout history. Without a connection to existing civilization, and without a source of easily accessible water provided by nature? No, we have never done that.
- dwild 8y agoWhat about the ISS? The water they consume is recycled and is clearly not provided by nature.
- lisper 8y agoThe ISS is very closely connected to civilization. It has real-time comms, and in an emergency a spacecraft can reach it in about six hours, or return an astronaut back to earth in less time than that. The longest it has ever gone between resupply missions is four months. The shortest time between resupply missions to Mars is two years.
- kakarot 8y ago> The shortest time between resupply missions to Mars is two years. You aren't going to be sending only one ship at a time. You will be staggering shipments, with 3-4 ships in transit at a time. You could make the time between resupplies as short as you want.
- jfoutz 8y agoResupply isn’t quite the right word. If I break the X, i have to fix it myself or wait 2 years.
- notyourwork 8y agoI think you are missing the bigger premise with colonization of another planet. I agree your challenge would be worth of consideration but the premise is that if earth due to some reason becomes uninhabitable having a colony on another planet gives human population ability to continue on. This is regardless of whether we have colonized every inch of this planet right?
- Retra 8y agoEarth is unlikely to ever become less inhabitable than Mars, even under the most pessimistic scenarios.
- yardstick 8y agoI think the original point was that you can practice and fine tune various techniques critical for Mars right here on Earth first. Makes sense to me. Let’s still reach Mars but let’s also make the best use of our resources here so we can minimise the failures over their. Not eliminate, but significantly reduce.
- bane 8y ago> There are vast tracts of uninhabited land on earth, notably in the American West. Colonizing those would be vastly easier than colonizing Mars, and yet no one is even talking about that. I think the principal problem here is that those places aren't on Mars.
- lisper 8y agoWhy is that a problem?
- bane 8y agoIf your plan is to go to Mars, and you end up in Tacna, AZ, you're going to be real disappointed.
- Retra 8y agoIf your plan is to go to Mars and you can't even survive Tacna, AZ, you're going to be dead. I suppose some people prefer that to disappointment, though.
- nkrisc 8y agoIf you want to study Mars, actually being there opens up new avenues of study. If you're going to study Mars from Earth, it doesn't make sense to do it from the Nevada desert.
- lisper 8y agoThat's true. But if you want to colonize Mars then it makes a hell of a lot of sense to practice first in some place like the Nevada desert.
- wyattpeak 8y agoWhat do you mean by this objection? There are several projects practicing surviving in isolated conditions for precisely that purpose.[1] Simply surviving on Earth, however isolated, is hardly helpful though. You need to simulate things like the lack of an atmosphere to teach you anything useful. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_analog_habitat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_analog_habitat
- flopunctro 8y agoThe less-obvious difference between Mars and "anywhere on Earth" is that no amount of environmental (even tectonic) damage done on Earth is going to affect Mars. I'm not arguing that Mars is orders of magnitude harder than Nevada, but it covers the risk of "we fucked Earth".
- opencl 8y agoNo matter how badly we fuck up Earth with pollution/climate change/nuclear war/etc. it is still going to be a far more habitable place than Mars.
- aseipp 8y agoYes, but you see, only one of those possibilities allows me to live out a fantasy of being a cool space colonist like Matt Damon. The other one requires me to be a usual suspect who has to deal with the material outcomes of living in society. So, all things considered -- it's definitely way cooler to believe that Mars is the answer. And as someone who knows absolutely nothing about pollution, the environment, or Mars, but read every Isaac Asimov novel -- I think this isn't being given due consideration. You know what they say! If you can't make absolutely minimal changes to the political outcomes of your planet, you're absolutely ready to dart off into space onto planets with no breathable atmosphere or water that could have unknown effects on the human body and mind.
- jfengel 8y agoBut the risk of "we fucked Earth" to the point where it's harder to colonize than Mars is effectively nonexistent. You could set off every nuclear device at once and it would still be easier to live here than on Mars. Even a dinosaur-killing asteroid would still leave the planet easier to live on than Mars. (Many species did survive last time, even without technology.)
- hannob 8y agoI don't think anyone wants to colonize Mars because they're looking for land. They want to colonize Mars because it's super-cool to live on another planet. If it's feasible or makes sense is of course an entirely different question.
- rev_null 8y agoBiosphere 2 was meant as a self-sustaining ecosystem capable of supporting human life. It wasn't entirely successful, but was along the lines of what you described. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2
- lisper 8y agoBiosphere was an interesting experiment, but very different from what I had in mind. It relied on a huge up-front engineering effort, orders of magnitude more than what would be realistic on Mars. What I had in mind was a colonization effort in the desert starting with what you could realistically carry on a spacecraft, i.e. a few shipping containers (even that is being pretty generous) and then no outside contact for two years (at a minimum).
- makewavesnotwar 8y agoYeah, I've been making that argument since Musk and Bezos first announced their intentions (though I usually used terraforming Arizona as an example as that state has become one of the largest polluters per capita in the US). But the argument that guys like Bezos and Musk are clinging to is that Mars presents an opportunity to continue the human race in an event of cataclysmic proportions (like another massive asteroid strike, the Yellowstone caldera erupting at a scale we hadn't anticipated, or global warming making Earth generally uninhabitable). Being farther away from the Sun, Mars gets much much colder than Earth, but it never gets as warm (max temps are something like 60 - 70 degrees Fahrenheit). So it's substantially different than a place like the Nevada desert. I don't argue that we shouldn't be trying to terraform Earth first and reduce our reliance on positive feedback loop functions like air conditioning, quite the contrary. And I do believe all the rocket launches involved getting people to Mars would likely accelerate warming here on Earth. But Earth and Mars are vastly different places that are very far apart, and I think that's the argument for colonizing Mars. Also, you should look into Earthships.
- lisper 8y ago> Mars presents an opportunity to continue the human race in an event of cataclysmic proportions (like another massive asteroid strike, the Yellowstone caldera erupting at a scale we hadn't anticipated, or global warming making Earth generally uninhabitable). Even in a worst-case scenario we're better off here. We have a pretty good idea where all the dinosaur-killer-sized asteroids are and none of them are on a collision course with earth. There is the possibility of a medium-size rock causing some very serious damage to infrastructure, but it's not going to make us go extinct. Likewise for volcanic activity. Even a dinosaur-killer-sized rock is survivable (for the species, not for civilization) by moving underground for a while until the dust settles. Global warming is an existential threat to civilization, but not to homo sapiens as a species. We may have to go back to being hunter-gatherers in northern latitudes, but again, it's not going to make us go extinct. Homo sapiens are just damned tough to exterminate.
- jfk13 8y ago> trying to terraform Earth Interesting phrase ... isn't Earth "terraformed" already, by definition?
- WhompingWindows 8y agoYou're not considering the actual, non-hype reasons for colonization of Mars. It's about scientific discovery first and foremost, and the vast majority of "beings" there will be robots in early colonization. Look at what we've sent already: robots for scientific discovery. This pattern will continue for at least a couple decades, the first humans sent there will be technically minded to do maintenance on robots, build up a small base/solar arrays/propellant production. Putting fake bases in the West isn't going to do anything towards understanding Mars, its former ecosystems, and its current potential for harboring life. If you and everyone else has bought into the hype machine, well that sucks, but real scientists are still focused on robotics on Mars.
- cicero 8y agoThe article is about Mars One, which was about sending humans to Mars.
- lisper 8y agoI'm not opposed to the scientific exploration of Mars. I'm just saying that we are nowhere near ready to seriously consider colonizing Mars.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoYou're confusing "can't" with "don't want to". Nobody wants to colonize some desert patch, but many people want to colonize Mars for many different reasons. Self-sustaining will take time, but it's not unsolvable even with the current technology. It's just very expensive at the moment.
- lisper 8y ago"Very expensive" asymptotically approaches "unsolvable" for large values of "very". I do get that colonizing Nevada is nowhere near as glamorous and sexy as colonizing Mars. But if we can't do it in Nevada (and it is far from clear that we actually can) then Mars is just hopeless. You could do that experiment for a tiny fraction of the money being invested in launch vehicle development. If the results were negative, you could save an awful lot of money.
- short_sells_poo 8y agoBecause usually in the past, the big leap was not done by playing it safe, but by ignoring all the naysayers, disbelievers and those without imagination and doggedly doing the impossible only to discover that when push came to shove, solutions were found to previously impossible problems and when enterprising people put their heads together and do not consider failure an option, miracles can and do happen. Playing it safe can net small incremental improvements, but it won't capture people's imagination and it won't energize the human spirit to reach to the very bottom of our abilities. Playing it safe won't unite a large group of fundamentally egoistic beings for a common cause. I believe the biggest evolutionary leap that propelled humans to the top of the food chain is the enterprising human spirit, the pioneering drive, the irresistible urge to stick our fingers into the wallsockets of the universe. Sometimes we get shocked, and sometimes it hurts badly, but we strive becase we do not give up. We reach for the stars, and when we find ourselves in dire need because the cold, merciless and deadly vastness of space threatens our survival, we are pushed to find solutions that were deemed unthinkable otherwise. Perhaps the first shot only gets us to the moon, but we'd never reach it just plinking arrows. Early explorers set out into the unknown oceans knowing that they will likely not return. Many faced extreme hardship and regrettably died. But some survived and they wrote history as we know it. They were all ill-prepared, because they didn't even know what to prepare for. But it is their sacrifice that allowed us to discover new continents, to circumnavigate the world and connect pockets of humanity into an ever denser network of modern society. There was a time when scientists were convinced that humans will not be able to breathe if travelling faster than 40 mph. There was a time when human flight was thought impossible. It took a bunch of people jumping off cliffs and plunging to their death to figure out the details. Those jumps were necessary. Not just for lessons learned ("this is not the way to do it" is a valuable lesson!) but each of those jumps pushed the envelope a bit further. Each pioneer got a bit closer to the light at the end of the tunnel. The light in some tunnels ends up beign a train, but some tunnels end up leading to the bright spark of revolution. As much as logic dictates otherwise, we need dreamers who are irrational and fearless enough to go into the unkown. Without these dreamers, nobody will push the envelope. Most of them will be considered foolish, stupid and reckless in their time, but our history is built on the shoulders of those who succeeded against all odds.
- 8y ago
- lorenzorhoades 8y agoDo you believe this would be worth it? Do you think our society does not have sufficiently advances technology to start a self sustaining colony in the desert? I think it would be absolutely trivial, and i'm pretty sure someone has already planned this out and decided against spending the money.
- lisper 8y ago> Do you believe this would be worth it? Absolutely. > Do you think our society does not have sufficiently advances technology to start a self sustaining colony in the desert? I think the jury is very much out on that question. > I think it would be absolutely trivial I think you underestimate how much humans depend on their connections to civilization. Even surviving in benign environments (i.e. ones where water is available for free) for long periods of time is non-trivial.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]