2 ms·
> You are replacing 1000 low-skilled sweatshop workers > It's a complete win Complete win for who exactly ? How do you reconcile automation and the current e
by lm28469 8y ago
> You are replacing 1000 low-skilled sweatshop workers
> It's a complete win
Complete win for who exactly ?
How do you reconcile automation and the current economy of consumption ? As far as I can tell they don't work hand in hand very well.
These 1000 workers will still want their part of the cake, to do so you'll have to get them new jobs. I wouldn't be surprised if every time we go through a cycle of automation we also go one layer deeper in the "bullshit jobs" creation.
It's all fun and games until you have to take into consideration the soci-economical aspect of automation.
"Automation, the most advanced sector of modern industry as well as the model which perfectly sums up its practice, drives the commodity world toward the following contradiction: the technical equipment which objectively eliminates labor must at the same time preserve labor as a commodity and as the only source of the commodity. If the social labor (time) engaged by the society is not to diminish because of automation (or any other less extreme form of increasing the productivity of labor), then new jobs have to be created. Services, the tertiary sector, swell the ranks of the army of distribution and are a eulogy to the current commodities; the additional forces which are mobilized just happen to be suitable for the organization of redundant labor required by the artificial needs for such commodities." - The society of spectacle.
- 2019ideas 8y ago>Complete win for who exactly ? The sweat shop workers, the company, the customers. Sweat shop workers are losing their ability to do mindless labor, next up, they will be using their brains to make low skill decisions where automation cannot. Think Amazon Turk. Customers get lower cost, likely higher quality products. Company gets more reliable workforce. >It's all fun and games until you have to take into consideration the soci-economical aspect of automation. This has already happened in history. You COULD make it illegal, but then your countries technology will be out performed by another country. --- Its easy to disagree, its harder to come up with your own solutions.
- lm28469 8y agoWhat would be the end goal of such a system ? Looks to me like a rat race.
- 2019ideas 8y agoHigher standards of living. Less starvation, better environment, etc...
- pixl97 8y agoOnly if there is a taxation function that takes money from the top and distributes it, which gets derided as full on communism on HN. One of the big issues with automation is it tends to concentrate wealth with a few big players
- lm28469 8y agoThat's an honourable goal but automation was supposed to deliver* us in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, 00s etc .... It never happened and will never happen with the current world economy. These things are mutually exclusive. https://hbr.org/2016/02/todays-automation-anxiety-was-alive-and-well-in-1960 https://hbr.org/2016/02/todays-automation-anxiety-was-alive-... https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/SPT/v7n3/hong.html https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/SPT/v7n3/hong.html https://timeline.com/robots-have-been-about-to-take-all-the-jobs-for-more-than-200-years-5c9c08a2f41d https://timeline.com/robots-have-been-about-to-take-all-the-... * or destroy, depending on who you listen to
- fizixer 8y agoI'm sorry. Allow me to qualify my claim and restate it: It's a complete win for everyone except for the morons in charge, and their so-called expert economic advisers, who think the functioning of the society has to depend upon everyone needing to work 9 to 5, Monday through Friday in order to have food, shelter, clothing, health, education, justice. (Even if it means creating more and more bullshit jobs). If your pathetic obsolete-jobs-are-always-replaced-with-new-kinds-of-jobs economists cannot update their worldview and their economic policy in light of technological progress, that's not a problem with technological progress. (Only a handful of economists, Erik Brynjolfsson, Andrew McAfee, Robin Hanson, to name a few, have a realistic view of what's coming in terms of socioecononmic impact of tech progress).
- lm28469 8y agoI genuinely can't tell if you're passive aggressive and referencing the author of the quote as "pathetic economists", I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. Either way, look at the past 40 years of so of technical progress, it's mostly driven by personal power/wealth quests and has nothing to do with bettering society. People are still working as much as before (actually, society as a whole is working more), but instead of working for survival they're doing it for an enhanced form of survival which mostly consist of buying (gadgets) and consuming ("culture"). The need of buying an iphone n+1 keeps you going day in, day out while the new netflix show distracts you just enough to keep you sane until your next shift. IG / FB reminds you that "if you keep going you'll make it, eventually, maybe. Oh and btw don't forget to buy these new shoes that _influencer_xyz_ talked about". Amazon, Facebook, Apple, Netflix, Instagram, are enabler / distributer of mindless consumption, be it physical or "cultural". They're not bettering the world in any way. Meanwhile people in the US, one of the most powerful country/economy don't have a proper public health system and have horrendous working conditions. Keep in mind that as tech workers we're relatively immune to most of these things, we're generally above the daily struggle of the _true_ working class (flexible work hours, chill offices, good salaries, job safety) The entire world economy is based on work<>consume, if you remove half of the equation thinking that the system is going to self-regulate I doubt you fully grasp the issue. But hey, everything that's not full blow neoliberalism has to be communism, right.