6 ms·
Of course the problem is how are Google and Facebook supposed to determine what 'trustworthy, reliable news' is. If you read the Government report behind this a
by chrisseaton 8y ago
Of course the problem is how are Google and Facebook supposed to determine what 'trustworthy, reliable news' is. If you read the Government report behind this article you'll find that the Government's only suggestion seems to be literally 'you know it when you see it.' Seems very open to abuse and 'knowing' that news you don't like is untrustworthy 'when you see it'.
I think society in general is nearly at the point of basically declaring bankruptcy on trustworthiness of journalism and are treating everything as having an agenda. But then how can you fund news with an agenda from public funds?
- shaki-dora 8y agoThe BBC is without a doubt more trustworthy than the average story that goes viral on Facebook. Since the former is a product established by that government (with some indirection to remove it at least from day-to-day political influence), it seems not to be quite as impossible to judge the quality of a publishing operation as you make it out to be. Yes, people will invariably point to some instances of the BBC receiving flak for errors in judgement (edit: see below for examples). But if we collectively can no longer agree that there is a difference between the BBC and, say, infowars, then we have lost anyway, and all that’s left is to gleefully watch civilization circling the drain.
- chrisseaton 8y ago> it seems not to be quite as impossible to judge the quality of a publishing operation as you make it out to be I agree the BBC is more trustworthy than other sources. But if we're talking legislation how do we write a rule for that? Do we literally legislate 'the BBC, the Telegraph, ... are trustworthy'? Or do we write a qualitative test? But then what is the test? As I said the best idea at the moment seems to be literally 'you know it when you see it'. Which doesn't work.
- shaki-dora 8y agoOne tree is not a forest. A million trees is a forest. Nobody can tell you which single tree delineates the difference. That doesn’t stop us from calling a tree a tree and a forest a forest. The tech community has this idea that it’s impossible to make laws affecting such concepts that cannot easily be expressed as an algorithm giving boolean answers. But in reality, that’s exactly what jurisprudence does for a living. Otherwise there would be no need for lawyers and judges and juries. The “I know it when I see it” quote is, obviously, one coined by a judge, and a supreme one at that. It became famous for both being somewhat true, and for leaving us wanting for something better. And even though the definition of pornography has somewhat advanced since then, and become somewhat less relevant, there still is a gray area: some gangbang on pornhub is probably porn. A bag of Doritos is not porn. In between are the image of Kim Phuc, Michelangelo’s David, and many a work of art. But the existence of that gray area does not negate the possibility to definitively say that the bag of Doritos is not porn, as far as the law is concerned.
- sbmassey 8y agoLegislation requires more precise definitions if it is to be useful in court.
- shaki-dora 8y agoThere are quite a few laws concerning both pornography and forests, and civilization has steadfastly refused to die.
- timthorn 8y agoThe view of the Man on the Clapham Omnibus is useful in court but not very precise...
- pjc50 8y agoYou'd be amazed how much legislation just says "reasonable" and leaves the court to the details.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAs some one said to me "as so many MP's are lawyers its a favour (billing opportunity ) for their lawyer friends"
- RHSeeger 8y agoThe problem with laws that allow for "I'll know it when I see it" is that - The need to be vague/broad enough to allow anything that could be <thing> to be classified as <thing> under the law - The government actors are well know for acting in bad faith, ruining the lives of people that did nothing wrong because the law allowed for it. A teenage couple tried as adults for child pornography because they sent each other naked pictures of themselves. That is clearly not what the law intended, but the state went after them for it anyways. Vague/overly-broad laws can be abused. Any law that can be abused will be abused.
- Asooka 8y agoThe solution generally is "we form a department that employs qualified people and scores entities on quality X", then the law says "entities with less than 50% X as determined by the department for X scores shall not appear on the first page of results". As a programmer you should know that all problems can be solved with enough levels of indirection :) .
- pjc50 8y agoWell... while the BBC are clearly not Infowars, they have a longstanding problem with their current affairs coverage optimising for "controversy", by giving undue prominence to far right views. Latest iteration of this: https://twitter.com/cstross/status/1095279763009220609 https://twitter.com/cstross/status/1095279763009220609 / https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/bbc-question-time-investigating-after-13971180 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/bbc-question-time-inv... My personal opinion is that the BBC's political coverage was thoroughly kneecapped after the Hutton Inquiry ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutton_Inquiry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutton_Inquiry ) at which point they decided to surrender to the government line rather than fight suspected falsehoods.
- arethuza 8y agoI'm generally a big supporter of the BBC but I really noticed how biased they were in the run up to the Scottish independence referendum - they really are quite conservative (note the small c) about some areas and that came across very strongly in a lot of reporting.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI'm also generally a big supporter of the BBC, but I think their left bias is extremely apparent on their radio content. It must be down to internal culture in different offices, because the bias is different in different parts of the Corporation. Might be a diversity problem in hiring?
- arethuza 8y agoThose on the left (e.g. Owen Jones) think it is a pillar of The Establishment and those on the right think it is has a left-liberal bias. I guess it is doing something right! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC#21st_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC#21st_cent...
- chrisseaton 8y ago
- kerng 8y agoDo make ad publishing more difficult- eg. Maybe large scale targeted individual ads to manipulate people (with targeted precision) should be illegal? Or ads that combine more then 1 selection criteria or whatever- the status quo is not defendable.
- strictnein 8y agoAll ads are designed to manipulate people. It's literally the purpose of advertising.
- kerng 8y agoCorrect, but not all ads can be customized for individuals at scale - that's the difference and that's the problem.
- strictnein 8y agoThere's been customized mass mailings for a long time. Google and FB weren't the first to collect lots of information about consumers and sell it to advertisers.
- pjc50 8y agoPolitical advertising on the internet in the UK should at least be made to follow the print advertising rules (imprint+cost accounting), and ideally the TV advertising rules (banned except for PPB)
- entity345 8y agoYes, they should know it when they see it. And if they happen to make a mistake the government will helpfully tell them what to correct.
- 2019ideas 8y ago>the government will helpfully tell them what to correct. >the government There is no 'the government'. The government is an entity of elected and unelected people. They have their own bias, their own friends, their own wants. I have stopped using Facebook because it sucks, but if the government sucks, I am forced to use them.
- entity345 8y agoThe government will be in touch to help you correct your thoughts.