5 ms·
What's England got to do with this, and who's the naked Brexit lady? He isn't saying agrarian is better than industrialised. He's saying industrialisation was
by benj111 8y ago
What's England got to do with this, and who's the naked Brexit lady?
He isn't saying agrarian is better than industrialised. He's saying industrialisation was forced on them by colonialisation.
Read about the Congo free state for example [1].
Also. The early stages of industrialisation aren't particularly good for a nations poorest, Britain's industrial revolution was not a land of plenty for the poor, they just went from being poor farm hands, to poor factory workers.
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congo_Free_State https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congo_Free_State
- huffmsa 8y ago> They had little if any money, but then they didn’t need it in order to live well – so it makes little sense to claim that they were poor. His argument is that you can't be poor if you don't have a concept of money, like in an agrarian society. You overlooked it because your brain knows it's not true. Quality of life is not a dollar amount. It's all of those graphs Gates shared. Not just the first one.
- almost_usual 8y agoIf quality of life isn’t a dollar amount then why aren’t more people comfortable distributing dollars amongst the public?
- huffmsa 8y agoI'll rephrase. It's not purely a dollar amount. It's what's available for you to do and buy with those dollars. Eventually we will just give everyone dollars. I firmly believe Pixar's WALL-E is our Marxist ideal future. But we're not there yet. Need better robots.
- benj111 8y ago$1 a day if you're a factory worker needs to pay your rent, and your food, and your fuel, then your support network has gone, so grandparents cant look after kids etc, etc. $1 a day for a farmer means they don't have those costs. Social networks are still in place, etc, etc. As you say, Quality of life is not a dollar amount.
- huffmsa 8y agoSo let's address that. Do you believe that quality of life for a randomly chosen person has improved since 1820? My reading of Hinkel is that he does not believe it.
- benj111 8y agoOf course life has improved since 1820. My reading of Hinkel was that comparing a farmer to a factory worker is an apples and oranges comparison, because its doesn't take into account the non monetary benefits the farmer has. I would rather be a farmer on $1 a day than a factory worker on $1 a day, because the factory workers $ has to buy so much more stuff.