23 ms·
Thanks for the clarity around the fork. IMO the split was, to your point, largely political. One camp made the argument that increasing the block size would pre
by arcticbull 8y ago
Thanks for the clarity around the fork. IMO the split was, to your point, largely political. One camp made the argument that increasing the block size would prevent people from being able to store the entire chain locally in support of decentralization, the other was arguing it was time to let go in favor of pragmatically maximizing transaction count and that those who cared would buy the storage necessary. I'm sure there was much more to it than that -- this felt like a power grab by Ver et al. I addressed the basics as I saw them of SegWit vs block size growth because the post I was replying to originally cited them, then edited them out after my reply.
As you say, it's probably a straw man to say that LN should accommodate everyone now. That said, bitcoin operates on a principal of anti-efficiency; the more we ask of it the worse it does. We can't apply the same standard that "of course it will get faster/better/stronger/more efficient" over time because it's designed to go the opposite way. We need active plans to scale, to move forward, to grow it. That's why I ask more of them -- not because they should know but they should have some conceptually cohesive idea to justify their $100B market cap -- exceeding Visas's at peak -- a decade into this experiment.
It's fair that my position could be more nuanced. I've yet to find a way to untangle decentralized (in as much as BTC hashpower is over 50% in Beijing's purview) from lawless.
In some ways that's the root of the issue. Aren't they synonymous? Without authority, whose to judge? Who's to say a transaction was legitimate? So what if it wasn't, it can't be reversed anyways. The scammers are, in my opinion, part and parcel. You can't have decentralized, trustless and permissionless without letting people do as they will with it. By definition, nobody in cryptocurrency is a scammer, the code is the law and they've found some loopholes. Or are they as intended? Who's to say?
51% attacks are part and parcel too. The longest chain wins. You've got more hash power, you've got the longest chain, you are truth. Beijing writes a strongly worded memo to the miners in China, and that happens immediately.
Without appealing to authority and the status quo there's a reason humans tend to organize hierarchically. Hierarchy is an abstraction and an optimization. Humans are messy, we make messy code, messy systems and as such we have to appeal to each other to undo them, and with this system, we can't.
I do wish you and the others forging ahead luck, of course.
- mikekchar 8y agoJust to be clear, I've not got a horse in the race :-) I've have some bit pennies that I mined when you could still do that with a CPU, but just for fun. I haven't really intended to use them for anything. I would like a decentralised payment system to emerge. I don't think it will be BTC in its present form, but I'm happy that they are working on the problem and demonstrating issues. I don't have enough time to argue effectively for why we need such systems (in first world countries, it is much less of an issue), so I'll just leave it at that :-)