5 ms·
Can anyone summarize what is going on here? It seems like a flamewar with graphs, and not interesting enough to invest the time in reading.
by colechristensen 8y ago
Can anyone summarize what is going on here? It seems like a flamewar with graphs, and not interesting enough to invest the time in reading.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoGates and Pinker are promoting the idea that the world is getting better overall, economically, and that poverty reduction is a real thing. They point to advances in economic development as a major driver of this. The 'rebuttal' is a little tricky. Hickel argues that the data is bad (at least before 1980's). Moreover, he argues that it's really only in China that people have dramatically 'come out of poverty' and that the data without China shows an increase in poverty. Hickel accuses Gates/Pinker et. al. of promoting 'hard neoliberal' (i.e. strong free market) ideals. I don't believe this characterization is fair. Hickel argues that neoliberal policies pursued by IMF etc. have led to setbacks and that China i.e. the 'winner' in this area is not capitalist, rather more or less 'statist/nationalist' etc.. Pinker is publicly lamenting this Hinker guy as 'far left' etc. which is an odd twist due to the ad hominem.
- sooheon 8y ago> Hickel accuses Gates/Pinker et. al. of promoting 'hard neoliberal' (i.e. strong free market) ideals. I don't believe this characterization is fair. Gates/Pinker are selling exactly the antidote to potential guilt for "kicking away the ladder". History makes clear that "free market" ideals never apply to ourselves, only to those colonies and developing nations the IMF and World Bank can coerce into line. Argentina had 2~3x Korea's GDP per capita in 1970, and now the relation has almost exactly flipped. You should know which country had stronger protectionist policies and which was sold out to the World Bank. Pinker is marketing these harmful policies as "enlightenment", and lying with statistics to ease affluent intellectual guilt.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoThere was effectively a uprising, a revolutionary coup and a dictatorship in Argentina during that time, causing enormous political turmoil. And your blaming this in the 'World Bank' and 'Capitalists'? No. Neoliberals had little to do with it. My comment stands: Pinker is not a neoliberal, and he's not even supporting neoliberalism. Frankly neither is Bill Gates. A 'neoliberal' would not support things like socialized medicine, or major investments in aid - which is exactly what Gates is trying to get the US to do. Is Gates calling for lower taxes? Austerity? No? Is Pinker calling for an end to socialized medicine? For 'Statoil' to be privatized? No.
- aglavine 8y agofor many people neoliberal is a tag for anything they don't like
- sooheon 8y agoDuring the same period, we have put presidents in jail immediately after the end of their term, others have fled with billions, another has committed suicide, and it's open knowledge that corruption is rampant and a handful of conglomerates own the country. Our very last president was impeached and thrown directly in jail due to a popular uprising. We had dictator presidents for decades. Park Chung Hee, widely credited with the Miracle on the Han, was a dictatorial strongman with little grand plan except that knew protectionist policies would allow Korea to trade favorably, and trade up the industrial ladder from textiles to shipbuilding. Gates and Pinker are giving ground on marginal issues like healthcare, but pushing the core agenda of "free markets make everyone's lives better".
- aglavine 8y ago"Thrown to jail", that's a big difference with Argentina. But more important, budget deficit was most of the time less than 2%.
- aglavine 8y agoI am from Argentina, and the "sold out to the World Bank" narrative is really harmful to my country. Stop spreading it, you're totally clueless about it. What really made us poorer is chronic budget deficit supported by debt and inflation, and systemic corruption that weak institutions can't fight. As an example, we have two ex-presidents-now-senators that are condemned by Justice System but protected by special legal status for senators and congress men.
- sooheon 8y agoDuring the same period, we have put presidents in jail immediately after the end of their term, others have fled, another has committed suicide, and it's open knowledge that corruption is rampant. We had dictator presidents for decades. Park Chung Hee, widely credited with the miracle on the Han, was a dictatorial strongman with little grand plan except that knew protectionist policies would allow Korea to trade favorably, and trade up the industrial ladder from textiles to shipbuilding.
- haberman 8y agoThis is a story of competing narratives. Pinker says the world is improving by most measures, and this is a credit to our global system (though of course there is always room for improvement). Many people, including Jason Hickel, strongly object to Pinker's characterization. They think the global system is fundamentally broken and flawed and we should be ashamed for letting it happen. Ultimately it's a capitalism vs. socialism fight.
- ddebernardy 8y agoThere's more to that in the post. Hickel also raises that e.g. the recent improvements are actually due primarily to China and East Asian tiger economies, which have had protectionist policies; the rest of the South, by contrast, have seen a degradation of their poors' situation on a backdrop of neoliberal policies.
- myspy 8y agoI wonder why no one includes other metrics like being happy with life and having a dignified job. Metrics that are important and overlooked. Well, I have a job, but I have to slaughter animals for it, is something I would consider here too.
- andrepd 8y agoThe cynic answer is that "happiness with life" and a "dignified job" don't make the bosses any money. Numbers on a spreadsheet on the other hand...
- amval 8y agoProbably because those things are much harder to quantify or are depending on cultural factors that make difficult to establish a comparison.
- phtrivier 8y agoTL;DR: anything that looks good is an oversimplification. We're all going to die miserable.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 8y agoI followed this a little bit when it popped up on Twitter last week. The fight appears to be about whether rising global prosperity is helping poor people or mostly just poor people in China; and around the edges, about whether your definition of poor is simply GDP, or includes other harder to quantify things like commons, or if you want to measure it against the US poverty line at purchasing power parity dollars. It's a kind of oblique attack on neoliberal globalist capitalism's potential to increase living standards for people at the bottom of the global income distribution. Hickel reckons Pinker and Gates and friends have been too self-congratulatory on the merits of neoliberalism. IMO globalist capitalism has increased living standards for the poorest people in countries that were well-run enough to take advantage of it, China in particular. But there's still lots of improvement possible and we shouldn't feel too smug about the current situation.
- barry-cotter 8y agoGDP per capita has increased everywhere but Africa and that appears to be improving now in Africa. Living standards as measured by deaths in childbirth, infant mortality, lifespan, healthy lifespan, education and literacy have improved almost everywhere, even in places with no economy of more dependent on aid like Afghanistan, Niger or Chad. The absolute number of people in poverty may not be declining much outside China but that’s a function of massive population growth, not a failure of neoliberalism. Neoliberalism has brought more people out of poverty than anything else, and it’s not a close race.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"Neoliberalism has brought more people out of poverty" How about just Economic Liberalism, and good governance, and not 'Neoliberalism'? Because the neoliberals want government out of almost everything, so they can sell all those Africans Nike shoes for 50x the cost to be made. In between the two arguments there's a fair point: China's growth can't be characterized as 'neoliberal' or else they would be a total open market! But there are strong capital controls, a politicized currency etc. etc. so it can't be called 'neoliberal'. I think 'basic economic freedom' with 'intelligent governance' and possibly 'national strategies' in key areas like natural resources where it makes sense (i.e. Statoil in Norway) or education and healthcare where there is a dramatic need. And yes - even economic protectionism in certain areas.
- abetusk 8y agoThis is Jason Hickel's rebuttal to Steven Pinker's response [0] to Hickel's letter in the Guardian [1]. Pinker advocates that the quality of life for people is, on average, getting better worldwide. Hickel's responses are a little subtle but here's my interpretation: 1. Hickel argues that Pinker's $1.7/day poverty line is too low to be used effectively as a standard of poverty and proposed a $7.4/day rate 2. Excluding China from the period of 1981 to 2000 and using $7.4/day as a measure of the poverty line, the global poverty rate actually increased (from 62% to 68%) presumably because of exclusionary policies from the IMF 3. Hickel argues that Pinker is a a capitalist and neo-liberal "apologist" and that Pinker is providing a more optimistic picture of reality than is warranted (and presumably things could be getting better faster with more realistic appraisals of the world state) 4. The measure of success for poverty reduction should be our global ability to reduce poverty from our wealth rather than absolute or relative numbers of poverty reduction The point about the poverty increase from excluding China from 1981 to 2000 (point 2 above) is that this interpretation of data shows that poverty is not monotonically decreasing and that policy has drastic impacts on the rate of poverty reduction. I believe Hickel is arguing that pro capitalist or pro neo-liberal sentiment hides bad policy decisions, also presumably made with a pro capitalist or pretending to be done with a pro neo-liberal sentiment (IMF). I think Pinker provides compelling evidence but I appreciate counter arguments like Hickel's as it provides a fuller picture of some finer points that might get lost. The IMF excluding the global south is information I hadn't known before and I imagine has drastic implications for the rate of poverty reduction worldwide. I think Hickel falls into the trap of reducing Pinker to a neo-liberal cheerleader when Pinker is trying to convey some very basic information but I also haven't read any of Pinker's books so the critique might be valid. [0] https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2019/01/31/is-the-world-really-getting-poorer-a-response-to-that-claim-by-steve-pinker/ https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2019/01/31/is-the-w... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/29/bill-gates-davos-global-poverty-infographic-neoliberal https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/jan/29/bill-g...