3 ms·
You can play devils advocate all day long, I always like to challenge my preconceptions. I only care because people's laissez-faire attitude towards crypto is p
by arcticbull 8y ago
You can play devils advocate all day long, I always like to challenge my preconceptions. I only care because people's laissez-faire attitude towards crypto is putting real peoples' hard earned money at risk through some fanciful delusion of 'moon soon.' I'd make as strong an argument against Herbalife if people came to its defense.
A currency has 3 objective functions: medium of exchange, unit of account and store of value. It objectively fails the third test. [1]
Re Venezuela: If Bitcoin is to replace the status quo it must show itself to be better than the existing. If it's effectively as good as the Bolivar who cares whether it's their government or a group of self-appointed open source finance champs who are doing it? I thought the goal was to avoid the ends, not the means?
Re $2.4B/yr, people who have no understanding of the system put their money in because a group of loud activists (existing "investors") are encouraging them to do so. This is to prop up their own "investments" at the expense of the new money. They are running out of people who are willing to throw down solely because "moon soon" which is what's forcing the price down in spite of all the rampant manipulation. It's unlikely to go anywhere but down due to the high new money requirement for even price maintenance. You don't hear anything bad out of crypto investors mouths because they require $2.4B in new money just to keep their bags afloat.
Re the snake den, I'm saying that in re: the idea that it's not a scam just because scams operate on it. It's designed in a way that precludes stopping scams, which makes it de facto complicit / transitively a scam. You may disagree, it's just an optimization to think of it that way.
Fine it's an investment, it's a bad one.
I'm not making the case that the internet is going nowhere because pets.com is going nowhere. The idea that you're buying into blockchain technology's future by owning bitcoin is like saying you're buying pets.com stock because you want to invest in TCP/IP, and that appears to be the MO for most blockchain investors. Finally, nobody's made a good case yet for a problem blockchain can solve better than any existing solution, whereas TCP/IP, I'd say, solved real problems from day 1.
If anything crypto is making the best case I've seen for accredited investor rules.
[1] http://money.visualcapitalist.com/infographic-the-properties-of-money/ http://money.visualcapitalist.com/infographic-the-properties...
- erulabs 8y ago> A currency has 3 objective functions: medium of exchange, unit of account and store of value. It objectively fails the third test. No. Value is subjective. I understand what you're saying, and for what ever its worth, I promise I don't sell old folks on crypto funds. > Fine it's an investment, it's a bad one. Good - we're on the same page. You have a value judgement. Don't pretend to be an authority on the subject beyond your _well heard_ opinion. > The idea that you're buying into blockchain technology's future by owning bitcoin is like saying you're buying pets.com stock because you want to invest in TCP/IP Yes, exactly. Money and industry turn out to be closely linked.