4 ms·
I’m no denier, I have facts. The declining hash rate, the declining price, the exchanges going under, the 85% of dApps that don’t have a single daily transactio
by arcticbull 8y ago
I’m no denier, I have facts. The declining hash rate, the declining price, the exchanges going under, the 85% of dApps that don’t have a single daily transaction on average, the miners shutting down, going out of business, steam, Microsoft, Expedia all stopping supporting crypto. And the price too. It takes some serious head in the sandmanship not to notice.
I will tell you this time is different in the same way you tell yourself on the way up each time it’ll be different and this time it won’t crash. What’s different this time is there are no new bag holders. They all lost their shirts last time around. The price relies on new bag holders because 1800 new BTC are generated by miners and then sold to pay the electricity bills. That’s $2.4 billion dollars per year in sales pressure. The more the price goes up the more the sales pressure goes up. $20K per bitcoin requires $13B in new bag holder money per year. $100K means $65B in new bag holder money per year.
You sidestepped all the issues I pointed out: usability, intentionally built to prevent stopping scams, fraud, illegal activity. How it can’t serve the needs of the public. Nothing. Just more religious/MLM/ponzi sales pitch of hope, pray, moon soon. You even said so where you mentioned it’s a good thing your idle useless capital is increasing in value for NO REASON.
- illumin8 8y ago> The declining hash rate, the declining price, the exchanges going under This has happened every previous cycle. When mining becomes less profitable, the hash rate declines and difficulty declines until it reaches equilibrium. Currently 1800 BTC are being created every day, but when the next "halvening" happens I wouldn't be surprised to see an increase in price as all of a sudden the same amount of demand is competing for half the daily supply (900 BTC). If you look at past cycles, the "halvening" has precipitated many BTC bull runs.
- arcticbull 8y agoAgain you side step. This time side stepped that everyone’s now heard of and been burned by btc which was not true prior to the last run up, that my figures are still astronomical whether halved or not, or quartered, or eighthed. That major companies were burned by it. VCs were burned by it. That people have come down from their hopium high and realized blockchain in and of itself won’t solve literally any problem it’s thrown at better than MySQL will. You side step explaining why you think your money should be magically worth more over time. The question is whether there’s still 2.4 or 1.2 billion in new cash to add every single year until the next “mooning” which if were using your own expectations will be followed by an equally horrific crash. Why would we use that kind of thing as a currency?
- illumin8 8y agoYou presume nobody was burned in the last 5 boom/bust cycles, and that VCs are too stupid to look at history before making an investment.
- topmonk 8y agoEverytime it's crashed it's recovered to a point where the low is now higher than the last peak. I am fully aware of that and expect if it zooms up again, it probably will crash again. I don't deny this. But if when it crashes it ends up higher than the last peak, who cares? I didn't sidestep your issues. I didn't address them directly, but that doesn't mean I didn't address them. They were as valid as they during the last crashes, and proven to not prevent a recovery then, so therefore the same issues do not prevent a recovery now. You weren't providing any reasons that a recovery like it did before, even in the face of all the issues you mentioned. Now you respond with a new reason: > What’s different this time is there are no new bag holders. They all lost their shirts last time around. The price relies on new bag holders because 1800 new BTC are generated by miners and then sold to pay the electricity bills. That’s $2.4 billion dollars per year in sales pressure. The more the price goes up the more the sales pressure goes up. $20K per bitcoin requires $13B in new bag holder money per year. $100K means $65B in new bag holder money per year. By "bag holders" you talk as if it's a big scam. Only it's not. Everything is out in the open for people to see, and no one is lying about what it is. Whether people in the future will choose to invest or not, and whether the industry will continue to grow or not is what determines whether the price will recover. You say there won't be any more of that, due to price pressure from miners, but again, there has always been pressure from miners and that didn't prevent recovery the last 5 times. I grant you the selling pressure from the miners has increased, but the size of the market has also increased as well. Also, due to block reward halving, they do not increase at the same rate. So, even if the selling pressure is too much currently, for the market to grow enough and make up for it, it will eventually reduce so that won't be the case forever. To repeat though, I also am not 100% sure bitcoin will be the dominate cryptocurrency. As I said before, I'm bullish on the cryptocurrency market in general, not just bitcoin.
- arcticbull 8y agoWhy would we use as a currency something that swings 90% back and forth every few years? That's an objectively awful currency. Imagine your checking account explodes from time to time, one week you can buy a mansion the next you can't afford rent. That should be QED for why this isn't viable - isn't this what it's supposed to be saving Venezuela from? Whether we call them bag holders or not, there's no guarantee there's another $2.4B/yr to maintain the current price let alone drive it up. It is not intrinsically a scam its just built in a way that explicitly makes it impossible to prevent scams. IMO by the transitive property, it's a scam. Let's say I own a coffee shop. I also know that it's a breeding ground for venomous cobras, but I refuse to let an exterminator in. If someone gets bitten there's no world in which I'm not going to prison. It's not fair to call what I have "just a coffee shop" is it? It's also not an investment, as you're not obtaining a share of ownership in anything. It's like calling Subway sub stamps an investment. They're just tokens I can redeem at Subway, not a 401(k). The market is now smaller than its been in terms of total market cap, in terms of transaction count, in terms of transaction volume, than it's been in 2 years: https://data.bitcoinity.org/markets/volume/5y/USD/coinbase?t=b&vu=curr https://data.bitcoinity.org/markets/volume/5y/USD/coinbase?t... All the other cryptocurrencies are even less used, less useful, and not even worth talking about, like Dentacoin -- your dental records but on the blockchain for no apparent reason. You know Visa's market cap is "only" $300B? At $100K bitcoin you have to buy, in cash, one whole new Visa every 4.6 years just to maintain the price.
- oska 8y agoYou're throwing out a lot of heat in this thread but not much light. To address just the very first 'factual' claim in your comment here: > I’m no denier, I have facts. The declining hash rate Please check the difficulty page on Bitcoinwisdom [1] and scroll to the bottom where the history of hash rate changes over the last year is shown. You will find that over the last year it has gone from 18,633,553,122 GH/s on January 25, 2018 to 43,390,041,906 GH/s on February 10, 2019. So more than doubled over the last year while the price was rapidly declining. You will also see that there was a drop in hash rate over November/December after a peak in Octeber last year but the trend is now back up again. And as I said above, the trend over the whole year is obviously up (it more than doubled). [1] https://bitcoinwisdom.com/bitcoin/difficulty https://bitcoinwisdom.com/bitcoin/difficulty
- arcticbull 8y agoYou are correct, I was referring to the drop from late August through mid December. I hadn't checked and assumed the trend continued, thanks for clearing that up!