5 ms·
>they got bored with it I've always wondered why Google is so bad at keeping various services going. Your comment caused me to reflect that Google hires a lot
by irrational 8y ago
>they got bored with it
I've always wondered why Google is so bad at keeping various services going. Your comment caused me to reflect that Google hires a lot of smart people. Smart people tend to get bored with working on the same thing and want to work on new shiny things. Could it be that the smart people at Google do a bang up job of creating new services, but then get bored and move on to something new, leaving the previous service to slowly die and eventually get abandoned?
- technofiend 8y agoProblem solvers are often (IMHO) also novelty seekers. Or looked at another way, who brags on their resume "I was hired by Google to be maintain the status quo!" Not many people want to be the Maytag Repairman. For those too young to understand the reference, Maytag's commercials suggested their appliances were so reliable that their repairman never had anything to do.
- pkaye 8y agoI think it is more the Google reward system forces the smart people to work on something new. They pay out for crazy new things that become wildly successful and everything else becomes roadkill. Its like the employees are part of little startups and the executives are VCs.
- northwest65 8y ago>I've always wondered why Google is so bad at keeping various services going I'm starting to believe that it might be simply because low quality software is hard to maintain. They have some very complex software, but nothing of great quality. They might hire a lot of smart people, but not very many that are actually good at developing quality software. It appears that being smart doesn't make you diligent in your work, or give you an eye for detail. Examples of this bad quality are simply everywhere; cursor left and right too fast in Google Image Search and that functionality breaks until you use the mouse to select the next image. Want to reply in Gmail, you have to click the reply button twice for the reply pane to appear. This is really basic stuff, and suggests a lack of competency in developing quality software, and a lack of care. They are huge, but they are actually not very good.
- Godel_unicode 8y ago> Want to reply in Gmail, you have to click the reply button twice for the reply pane to appear This doesn't happen to me, and a quick Google (ha) isn't turning up complaint posts about it. This might just be a you thing. Have you used Google maps? Or Google {search,photos}? I get the feeling that they have two very different grades of software they write, and the stuff written by the varsity is so good that it's invisible to it's users.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoI had to upgrade my two year old phone because GMaps was turning into a sluggish nightmare that wasn't usable on a non-retina display. Google has serious QC problems. Their varsity team still doesn't turn out best of class software.
- webreac 8y agoGoogle's software is "free". If it was too good, it would kill competition. Google has one fear: to be cut in pieces because of monopolistic behaviour. Google, Gmail, Google map and google translate have almost killed concurrency. Google doc is improving.
- uryga 8y agoi think you mean "the competition" instead of "concurrency". but i see where you're coming from, it's "konkurencja" in Polish :)
- treis 8y agoTo add to this, they can't even properly display screen saver photos on Chromecast from Google photos. My 4:3 photos get the top and bottom cut off instead of being letterboxed.
- Godel_unicode 8y agoWho's to say that your idea is proper? Letterboxing causes burn-in on OLEDs, not exactly ideal for a screen saver.
- SystemOut 8y agoThe incentive system at Google for promotion (which is where the dollars get much bigger) rewards launches, not maintenance work. You'll see hundreds of people on new products that are launching and hardly any full time engineers, excluding SREs, on products that literally bring in a billion dollars because they just work.
- AbrahamParangi 8y agoIt's because ads, google cloud, and a few other business units represent almost 100% of the revenue of Google (and parent company Alphabet). In a deeply fundamental way, every service or software product that isn't part of the revenue stream doesn't really matter to the business and there is no incentive to maintain it.
- nevir 8y agoGoogle's promotion process biases very heavily towards "impact". The problem is that maintaining existing projects generally isn't considered to be a demonstration of impact (or at least, it's a MUCH harder case to make). It's much easier to make the case that greenfield projects demonstrate impact. Additionally, engineers have a good amount of power over what they get to work on: managers generally have to convince them to join a team. It's nice in concept, but lacks a steady influx of unwitting new engineers to help support all the not-so-sexy projects (like many other companies). …so, you tend to see a pattern of engineers building a new thing, launching it, and then moving on to the next project. Leaving a trail of poorly supported projects in their wake.
- xiphias2 8y agoEngineers lost a lot of their power from the Eric Schmidt days. It's the PMs that are fighting for controlling engineers now, and killing projects that the engineers are working on (thereby stopping engineers from getting the promotion they work for). The promotion process is how you described though, PMs don't get promoted for maintaining projects, or even improvement on some metrics (that engineers are very good at), they always want new shiny stuff to brag about.
- hbarka 8y agoThe old Google Finance site was one of the better finance and stocks portal you could go to. Now it’s shite.
- auiya 8y agoCan vouch. When you see an organization behaving a specific way, you can usually assume it's due to how they structure their employee incentives. Conversely, watch how the organization deploys its lymphocytes if you want to know what it considers harmful.
- sixothree 8y agoMeh. It's just because it no longer captures any interesting data about its users.
- jayd16 8y agoIf the problem is really that Google doesn't hire any phone polishers and is hyper focused on new products, does it make sense for Google to spin off projects into somewhat independent subsidiaries? I have no idea if this is feasible within Google but it seems like breaking out some of Google's products into units with relaxed and/or focused hiring policies might help project cohesion. Seems like such a system could let Google keep its core campus type culture and also allow for better long haul support of certain projects. Then again, if its just a matter of cutting any project that won't make billions, the point is moot.