3 ms·
Bad logic. The presence of a plausible hypothesis doesn't prove causality! This mistake is like 80% of bad science. How many times are we going to repeat it?
by ajross 8y ago
Bad logic. The presence of a plausible hypothesis doesn't prove causality! This mistake is like 80% of bad science. How many times are we going to repeat it?
The counterfactual I provided is just an obvious example of the fallacy. The real meat of the argument was in that post too -- it's far more likely (Occam and all) that people are predicting recessions because every dummy can see that a recession is likely following the end of an expansion than that there is some kind of magical effect on public thinking.
This is just politics. You don't want your favored entity to get blamed for a recession, so you find a way to make that recession the "fault" of your political enemies. But no, growth cycles are cycles for a reason, and we don't need "fault" to describe what happens.
- toasterlovin 8y agoI was commenting strictly on your analogy. I agree that correlation does not equal causation.
- pessimizer 8y agoThe entire point of the analogy is that it is well known that sentiment does not affect the weather.