8 ms·
Is there a recent enough article documenting the frequency of the word “recession” in the news articles from the last 3-6 months? I’m asking because I remember
by paganel 8y ago
Is there a recent enough article documenting the frequency of the word “recession” in the news articles from the last 3-6 months? I’m asking because I remember reading an article in The Economist printed in the first part of 2008 where some economists had shown a correlation between the use of the word “recession” in mass-media and the probability of a recession actually taking place.
- puranjay 8y agoGiven that economic activity is so heavily influenced by "sentiment", which is shaped by media, I don't doubt that you're true
- masklinn 8y agoSurely a simpler explanation is that we're not terminally stupid as a species and are able to see — and thus talk about — looming recessions? As in, there's a correlation between heatwaves and A/C use. You could hypothesise that A/C cause heatwaves, but the simpler and fairly obvious explanations is that people use their A/C more during heatwaves.
- puranjay 8y agoThere is an entire field of economics which basically rejects the idea of human beings being rational economic actors and making decisions based on sentiment. If enough people tell you that there is a recession, it's not impossible to think that a significant minority will ignore the numbers and actually start believing it.
- ajross 8y agoUh... and why would such a correlation be notable? I mean, at the peak of expansions[1] everyone likes to predict recessions. That's literally the same logic as noting that people in the tropics tend to search "hurricane" in August and concluding that the resulting storms are Google's fault. [1] Check the stock market or some other favorite grown metric. Things hit a peak level about a year ago and have been mostly flat ever since. This is what the peak of a growth cycle looks like; every one can see that.
- toasterlovin 8y agoBad analogy. There is a plausible mechanism by which consumer sentiment—and, thus, the economy as a whole—can be influenced by media reports. There is no similar mechanism by which the weather can be influenced by media reports.
- ajross 8y agoBad logic. The presence of a plausible hypothesis doesn't prove causality! This mistake is like 80% of bad science. How many times are we going to repeat it? The counterfactual I provided is just an obvious example of the fallacy. The real meat of the argument was in that post too -- it's far more likely (Occam and all) that people are predicting recessions because every dummy can see that a recession is likely following the end of an expansion than that there is some kind of magical effect on public thinking. This is just politics. You don't want your favored entity to get blamed for a recession, so you find a way to make that recession the "fault" of your political enemies. But no, growth cycles are cycles for a reason, and we don't need "fault" to describe what happens.
- toasterlovin 8y agoI was commenting strictly on your analogy. I agree that correlation does not equal causation.
- pessimizer 8y agoThe entire point of the analogy is that it is well known that sentiment does not affect the weather.
- pessimizer 8y agoIt's not a bad analogy, it's an alternate explanation of how you could see the same effect without any causal relationship between recession sentiment and actual recession. Another example are quack cures: unusual cures are tried when people are at their sickest, then people improve, and they credit the improvement to the cure. Almost everybody who is very sick gets better, though, and the rest are too dead to denounce the cure as fake.
- MetricT 8y agoIf you're looking for a good predictor, look at the 10 yr/2 yr yield curve. When it inverts, a recession normally follows in 12-24 months, and it will likely invert in March. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/T10Y2Y https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/T10Y2Y The smart money has been getting out of the market for some time. But you can't sell unless someone else wants to buy. So at the end of the business cycle there is usually a blizzard of "the economy will keep doing good" articles contrary to common sense, trying to get the rubes to buy so the smart money can bail, await the crash, and then buy the stock back at pennies on the dollar.
- bb88 8y ago1. Correlation is not causation 2. The "cause" of 2008 was not media reports, but years of actual bad behavior by banks. Now if you want to rewrite history, awesome, but be transparent about it.
- umanwizard 8y agoI don't think GP's post implied that the link is causal.
- bb88 8y agoThen why bring it up without saying that? It sparked an entire thread about what makes a "causal" relationship.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 8y agoI mean, assuming economists know what they're talking about (which is a big ask) it would make sense that a looming recession causes articles about a looming recession, so the correlation makes sense. A complete lack of correlation would be one hell of an indictment, as it'd mean recessions out of nowhere and nobody having the remotest of clues.
- bb88 8y agoThen why bring it up? Either it means economists were right about 2018 (correlation) or it means they caused the recession -- indirectly or directly -- by warning people about it (causation).
- simonsarris 8y agoWell, you can see search interest: https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=recession https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=r... The dip "out" of recession interest in mid 2008 is interesting. Also interesting that you can spot 2011, when "double dip recession" came into popularity as a buzz-phrase. (see for example at the time: https://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/08/business/economy/american-economy-on-the-verge-of-a-double-dip-recession.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/08/business/economy/american...)