4 ms·
Because people don't keep track of all the buzzwords. FTA: > “reverse innovation”: taking a technology or solution born of the resource constraints in developi
by gowld 8y ago
Because people don't keep track of all the buzzwords.
FTA:
> “reverse innovation”: taking a technology or solution born of the resource constraints in developing countries and adopting it in wealthier ones.
Nothing "reverse" about it; the question is why rich countries don't import low-cost low-tech solutions from poor countries.
I presume the answer is profit motive.
The classic example that has been hiding in plain sight for decades is "so many expensive drugs that are about as good as cannabis, and cannabis still illegal."
- kiba 8y agoPresumably because wealthier nations are cost insensitive. They don't feel the need to reduce wastes in their healthcare system when they can 'afford' it.
- aetherson 8y agoThey may also feel that it's not actually lower-cost for them. For example: say your doctor uses a somewhat lower-tech, kitbashed uterine balloon on your wife during postpartum bleeding. And say she dies anyway (as someone surely will). There is going to be a real temptation to sue the pants off the hospital and say, "Look, they used some jury-rigged contraption instead of the gold-plated device that would have cost 10x." And, I mean, that's a bad look for the hospital in front of a jury, "Yes, well, this might be a little worse, but it might not, and it cost less money!" Everyone wants healthcare to cost less until it starts to look like hospitals or doctors are prioritizing "profits" versus people's lives.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoThis is why we pay the most of any other country... we try for best outcomes. If something cheap is used in the UK with a 97% good outcomes, we will spend 3 million to ensure we get closer to 98% outcome.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoDepending on the amount of patients, even a 1 percent point increase for $3M could be a baragin. If, e.g., everyone undergoes such procedure once in their lifetime, 1% times the population of UK is 660K people that could be saved for $3M, roughly $4.5 per life saved, which is a no-brainer.
- WrtCdEvrydy 8y agoYes, but we spend on better outcomes for things that aren't remotely critical. Women in the US have a C-Section rate of 26% compared to the 10 to 15% average just because doctors want better outcomes.
- nicoburns 8y agoIt seems like the real problem here is suing culture. I'm pretty sure the hospital would win that case here in the UK. As they should, because money saved in one person's treatment, means money that can be spent on someone else's (and the more cost-efficient the treatments, the better the overall level of care).
- specialist 8y agoI've long argued that we need a separate court system for medical & healthcare cases. Our current civil courts aren't set up (conceptually) to consider best available science and standards of care at the time of treatment. So we get pathological outcomes like overuse of cesarean delivery because one jury one time bought the argument that vaginal births caused cerebral palsy. And there's really no formal way to undo these bad legal precedents.
- bsder 8y ago> Nothing "reverse" about it; the question is why rich countries don't import low-cost low-tech solutions from poor countries. Simple: Because you will never make your money back running that device through FDA approval. Especially if there is already another device in that space. If you want the cheaper versions available, just get some charity like the Gates foundation to shepherd them through the FDA approval process. After that, lots of manufacturers will be happy to build them.