3 ms·
I lost faith on Raspberry Pi when they went anti-consumer by implementing some DRM bullshit[0] using their firmware blob together with a dedicated crypto chip i
by snvzz 8y ago
I lost faith on Raspberry Pi when they went anti-consumer by implementing some DRM bullshit[0] using their firmware blob together with a dedicated crypto chip in their camera accessory to prevent third party cameras from working. Nevermind the extracted key that's circulating through the net: The crypto chip is itself not cheap and totally unnecessary if not for the DRM.
So, until they backtrack and apologize for their disgusting anti-consumer behavior, there's no way I will buy or endorse their products in any way. There's plenty of highly competitive alternatives[1] and absolutely no need to buy from these crooks.
[0]: https://np.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/7npv6a/20_raspberry_pi_alternative_runs_android_and/ds3z7m7/ https://np.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/7npv6a/20_raspberry...
[1]: https://www.hackerboards.com/ https://www.hackerboards.com/
- nexuist 8y ago....Can't you just use a USB camera? https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/usage/webcams/ https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/usage/webcams/
- jwr 8y agoI have done some hardware design work with the RPi Compute Module and two CSI cameras. There is indeed an authentication chip on the cameras you buy from the RPi foundation. From what I understand, the idea here is to limit the drivers, so that the auto-tuning software (adjusting color balance, brightness, etc) only works with the original camera, not with clones. There is nothing that prevents you from connecting other CSI cameras (there are plenty available), or writing other drivers. It's just that the auto-tuning functions of the original drivers will only be enabled for original cameras. The driver authenticates the camera(s) at startup, and if they are not the original ones, disables the auto-tuning. The Foundation says it is a way of securing a revenue stream and recovering some of the cost of R&D work that went into the drivers. I can see how that is a compromise that could be chosen. Personally, while I am not a fan of locked-down solutions, I find it hard to get as outraged at this as some other people apparently are.
- snvzz 8y ago>From what I understand, the idea here is to limit the drivers, so that the auto-tuning software (adjusting color balance, brightness, etc) only works with the original camera, not with clones. That's not nice, or is it now?
- qhwudbebd 8y agoCan't agree more. I used to think they were doing the best they could, subject to their eye-wateringly poor taste in SoC manufacturer. But these kinds of shenanigans and playing the artificial scarcity game with the RPi0/0w made a very convincing argument to go elsewhere for project SBCs, if the horrible bcm283[567] wasn't reason enough. Fortunately, for a little more money, you can get far nicer boards that run fine with mainline kernels and without binary-only boot loaders, e.g. the current crop of RK3399 boards which even have 4GB RAM, USB3 and NVMe interfaces.