5 ms·
That's how Chromium is planning to work in the future. People don't want such a crippled system. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18973477 https://news.ycom
by lern_too_spel 8y ago
That's how Chromium is planning to work in the future. People don't want such a crippled system. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18973477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18973477
- scarface74 8y agoI read through the article and people were saying that the static rules limit its effectiveness. I haven’t noticed any difference between the effectiveness of ad blocking in iOS and using something like AdBlock for Chrome on desktops. It seems like people don’t trust the motives of Google (and rightfully so).
- lern_too_spel 8y agoNo need to look at motives. The end result matters, and the end result makes it as crippled as Apple's solution. Luckily, Android users will continue to have other options.
- scarface74 8y agoPrivacy invasive options which kind of defeats half the purpose of ad blockers. And those “other choices” only work within the browser. Apple’s ad blocking framework works with apps that embed web views using the SafariViewConttroller like Feedly.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoAnd non-privacy invasive options. Your point is a very poor one. Android users can use options that are worse than iOS options, the same as iOS options, or better than iOS options. Most will use the last category, as you would expect. Android also supports blocking ads throughout the system, not just in WebViews, which is the only option on iOS.
- scarface74 8y agoCan you guarantee that your ad blocking framework is not recording and selling your data or be sold to another company that will? You can buy VPN subscriptions that serve as ad blockers outside of the App Store and just go into settings and configure it yourself. Preferably, host your own VPN host on your computer where you know no third party is intercepting and recording your traffic.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoMore than on any other platform. Unlike Apple, F-Droid has reproducible builds.
- scarface74 8y agoRight like most users are going to build their own apps and install them. Also, are you going to personally audit every line of code?
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThat's not how it works. I'm also not saying that it's perfect, but it is clearly better than Apple's alternative, which you have not disputed.
- scarface74 8y agoYou just said you have reproducible builds. Either you are going to audit the code and do the build yourself or you are still trusting a third party.
- bepvte 8y agoI think you can agree that being able to see the code, and detect patched builds, makes it much more risky to pull something like this.
- fonosip 8y agoWe have a product for this. Consumer shared Adblock VPN. Or dedicated cloud or local builds for businesses. https://ba.net/adblockvpn https://ba.net/adblockvpn
- Marsymars 8y agoI notice a pretty marked difference between the best ad blocker I could find for iOS (1 BlockerX) and uBlock Origin on Firefox. The difference in utility is stark enough that if I'm on the road and need to browse the web outside of known-safe sites, I find it more pleasant to do so on my 5.7" Android phone than on my 10" iPad.
- scarface74 8y agoWhat are some sites where ads get through with 1Blocher?
- Marsymars 8y agoIt's not just ads, it's also not having the ability to only allow 3rd-party scripts and frames via whitelist. Since I don't use Safari for "normal" browsing, I can't recall any specific problematic sites, but just opening some random news headlines I get the following unwanted behaviours, roughly half of which are nags to install the iOS app: * theverge.com - nag to disable ad blocker * nbcbayarea.com - nag to install app * youtube.com - nag to install app, autoplaying video, all the rest of the junk that YouTube annoyances blocklist blocks for me with uBlock: https://youtube.adblockplus.me/ https://youtube.adblockplus.me/ * lifehacker.com - annoying animated recommended story gif (to be fair this isn't an ad-blocking issue, it's just a configuration setting that Safari doesn't offer) * bloomberg.com - nag to install app, nag to subscribe * forbes.com - nag to install app * observer.com - autoplaying video ad * twitter - app nag, login/signup nag
- scarface74 8y agoI’m not getting some of the app install nagware, but I’m also not getting them when I disable content blockers so it may just be a cookie thing. Also I couldn’t manually block the nagware on the NBC site using the share extension. I only use YouTube mostly for official AWS videos and then I use CornerTube. I usually don’t see ads. Do content producers get to choose when ads are shown?
- 8y ago
- tyingq 8y agoIOS allows you to change rules on the fly. The chrome proposal says they are static and unchangeable, other than whitelisting specific pages. You can't, for example, add or delete a rule. The only way to change rules is to submit a new version of your extension. One assumes that wasn't an accidental design flaw.