2 ms·
This is trivially disproven by the fact that Bach was one of a couple of hundred or so contemporaries across Europe who were also paid to compose full time. Mu
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
This is trivially disproven by the fact that Bach was one of a couple of hundred or so contemporaries across Europe who were also paid to compose full time.
Music theory was much more homogenous then. You could learn everything there was to know in a few years, and after a few more years of work you would be considered competent and ready to enter the job market.
What made Bach different was a long family background of music ('Bach' was practically a synonym for musician in some parts of Germany), and an insane work ethic - he literally walked across Germany to try to get an apprenticeship with a teacher, and he was on top of current developments in the rest of Europe in a way his contemporaries weren't.
But mostly he was a freaking genius - e.g. known for improvising eight-voice fugues, which is something no one else would even consider.
For every discipline there's a certain skill level which no amount of hard work will conquer without a foundation of raw talent - and he lived there.