3 ms·
There are a number of counter arguments to the parent article in "Why I'm not going to switch to Wayland yet."[1] On the subject of leaving the responsibility
by pmoriarty 8y ago
There are a number of counter arguments to the parent article in "Why I'm not going to switch to Wayland yet."[1]
On the subject of leaving the responsibility of taking screenshots to the Wayland compositor:
"for simple things using the compositor's screen shot tool is fine. But what if I don't like the screenshot tool for my compositor of choice? My experience with the GNOME screenshot tool (granted this was pre-wayland) was that it wasn't as good as, say, shutter, which has a lot of options, let's you easily crop and edit the screenshot from inside the screenshot tool etc. And then swaygrab doesn't even (currently) have an option to capture a rectangular region."
There are some other things "Why I'm not going to switch to Wayland yet" mentions which are important to me, like Wayland's lack of color picker tools and xdotool functionality.
The parent article says:
"Wayland doesn't have network transparency! This is actually true! But it's not as bad as it's made out to be. Here's why: X11 forwarding works on Wayland. Wait, what? Yep: all mainstream desktop Wayland compositors have support for Xwayland, which is an implementation of the X11 server which translates X11 to Wayland, for backwards compatibility. X11 forwarding works with it! So if you use X11 forwarding on Xorg today, your workflow will work on Wayland unchanged."
So why wouldn't I just use xorg to begin with?
Overall, Wayland just seems immature to me, and not a viable competitor to Xorg, which has had all of this functionality for decades. As an Xorg user, I really struggle to come up with compelling reasons to switch.
[1] - https://old.reddit.com/r/wayland/comments/85q78y/why_im_not_going_to_switch_to_wayland_yet/ https://old.reddit.com/r/wayland/comments/85q78y/why_im_not_...
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y ago>screenshot quote I addressed this in my article, please read it. And you can select a rectangular region on sway today, using tools which are portable across many Wayland compositors. >So why wouldn't I just use xorg to begin with? You can, no one's stopping you.
- cannabis_sam 8y agoIt’s still fuckin sad that we haven’t managed to build something lasting..