5 ms·
> knowing that a ring is “like a group...” is useful Turns out, not so much, though. The ring theory bears surprisingly little resemblance to the group theory,
by Koshkin 8y ago
> knowing that a ring is “like a group...” is useful
Turns out, not so much, though. The ring theory bears surprisingly little resemblance to the group theory, to the point that these concepts seem to have nothing to do with each other...
- nerdponx 8y agoExcept that a ring is literally a group under addition? Do you seriously mean to suggest there's no pedagogical value in using groups to teach rings?
- ginnungagap 8y agoThere's actually a big debate between math educators on whether abstract algebra courses should follow a groups first or a rings first approach so it is totally possible to teach rings without appealing to groups. (I'd still argue that both approaches have their advantages and disadvantages and that there can be value in using groups to teach rings though, I just wanted to say it's not as obvious as you might think)
- throwawaymath 8y agoI could be wrong here, but my read of that comment is that they're talking about the structural differences between rings and groups at the research level. Which I guess makes sense, since you're in very different territories if you're talking about something like representation theory of finite groups... Otherwise I agree with you, there's a lot of pedagogical value in combining coverage of algebraic structures.
- dnautics 8y agoYes obviously you need to know what a group is to even begin ring theory but ring theory looks and feels nothing like group theory.