4 ms·
I find it very hard to believe that paper ballots are actually more reliable. I'd imagine they're just much harder to detect errors so we can't assess how bad t
by tootie 8y ago
I find it very hard to believe that paper ballots are actually more reliable. I'd imagine they're just much harder to detect errors so we can't assess how bad they are.
Electronic ballots really shouldn't be a very difficult engineering challenge. We're already doing all of our financial transactions electronically and mistakes are relatively rare with an absolutely massive volume of transactions.
- burlesona 8y agoI agree with your sentiment, nevertheless every time I've used an electronic voting machine I've found it very clunky and difficult to operate. It's kind of amazing to me, it feels like the kind of thing that the hacker news crowd could solve in a long weekend. Of course it must be more complicated than that, but even the basic user interface always feels wrong. Just let me push a button that has the candidates name on it or directly above it. Oh well.
- greglindahl 8y agoAs a member of the "hacker news crowd", I think that paper ballots make a great solution to bad UI for an electronic voting machine. My county uses the paper ballot system described above.
- rebuilder 8y agoMaybe having the skillset to design a reasonably usable voting machine also means having an understanding of why electronic voting is problematic, and wanting to have nothing to do with them...
- specialist 8y agoYou think electronic voting could be preferable paper ballots? I checked and your county still offers touchscreen voting devices. Probably 1 per poll site, and at the early voting center, to comply with HAVA.
- greglindahl 8y agoI clearly said the opposite, but since you seem to be confused: I prefer paper ballots.
- specialist 8y agoI just wanted to be sure. A claim that the problem with electronic voting is bad UI could imply that fixing the UI would fix electronic voting.
- rsynnott 8y agoThere are two major problems with electronic voting. (a) It's often not implemented very well (either due to malice or incompetence; probably a bit of both in some cases). (b) When something goes wrong, and it will, there's often no reliable way to figure out what or to fix it. With sufficient effort, a 100% reliable paper count can be produced. Of course in many cases it may not get that effort, but it's possible, and this attribute is particularly important in an audit.
- tootie 8y agoWith sufficient effort a provably 100% reliable electronic system can be created.
- specialist 8y agoLet's wait until that system exists before we consider using it.
- cmurf 8y agoThere's reason to be suspicious of both systems, and insert the proper fraud and auditing measures for either system. It's not like election fraud didn't happen with paper ballots: ballot box stuffing and entire ballot boxes sunk into lakes. The thing is, mitigating this for a physical system like paper ballots, requires fairly basic training to become a poll monitor. Whereas the auditing of electronic systems is substantially more complicated, not least of which when for-profit companies compel the county/state into NDA's baring 3rd party audits, which happens to be the case in Georgia.
- Kephael 8y agoI would trust a voting system that spit out a hashed representation of my vote more than paper ballots. Paper ballots can be fabricated or misplaced. We witnessed people transporting votes in their personal vehicles in Broward county so there's no real chain of custody along with no verification of identity.
- specialist 8y agoHow would that hash prove your ballot was included in the final tally? If that story is true, that's a problem with Broward County, not with paper ballots.
- specialist 8y ago"We're already doing all of our financial transactions electronically and mistakes are relatively rare with an absolutely massive volume of transactions." Voting (election administration) is not double entry accounting. What you want would require every single person being required to cast a ballot and every ballot be counted. It'd also eliminate the possibility of the secret ballot. Are you sure that's what you want?