5 ms·
On the flipside, knowing that a ring is "like a group (which we already covered), with another operation that follows these axioms" is useful, and still mostly
by nerdponx 8y ago
On the flipside, knowing that a ring is "like a group (which we already covered), with another operation that follows these axioms" is useful, and still mostly rigorous.
It's better than "eh just use it a lot and you'll figure it out."
- throwawaymath 8y agoTrue, but that likeness is normally taught in abstract algebra without requiring category theory. For example this: https://i.redd.it/yqnbigi032i11.png https://i.redd.it/yqnbigi032i11.png doesn’t require any category to understand.
- mlevental 8y agothat's definitely a neat diagram but the examples (the blue) almost entail already know the definitively.
- nerdponx 8y agoNot my point. For education, there is a happy medium between providing theoretical context and hand-waving over technicalities and learning by example. Very nice diagram though.
- throwawaymath 8y agoTo give credit where it's due, that diagram is from a /r/math thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/99y547/my_digram_of_abstract_algebra_and_other_stuff/ https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/99y547/my_digram_of_a...
- zozbot123 8y agoAnd "these axioms" are indeed the axioms of a monoid operation (for multiplication), plus some sensible notion of "consistency" with the underlying abelian-group structure. Which is all that the "monoid object" characterization is saying, actually. So, I disagree that the perspective is inherently unintuitive.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI think you may have a different definition of intuitive than the top level comment, or else you two are speaking to different things. Category theory is certainly "elegant" and provides a lot of insight in the connection between various algebraic structures. But I think it would be completely asinine to use category theoretic formalisms in a first course covering algebraic structures like groups, rings and fields. That level of abstraction doesn't make the distinctions between each structure more intuitive; if anything it obfuscates them and requires setting up far more machinery to explain what they even are. It would be highly inappropriate for an undergrad's first exposure. That is my impression of the top level comment's point, and I largely agree with it. If you understand what a group is, I can explain what a ring is to you in a very straightforward way that still shows you the connections between the two things. But setting up category theoretic language would take up a nontrivial portion of the course itself, and at the end you'd have a much less specific understanding of the relevant theorems on rings and groups. You'd be missing all the trees for the forest.
- zozbot123 8y agoLook, it's 2019. "Setting up category-theoretic language" is something that should begin in the first lesson of the first course in formal, non-K12 math, starting with the use of ETCS or a comparable "structural" set theory as the 'naïve' foundation of choice. It provides countless advantages not just in abstract algebra, but in a wide variety of other subfields of math as well.
- throwawaymath 8y agoTo be clear, how much category theory are you envisioning setting up in a first course on abstract algebra? Are you basically just talking about a modern treatment of morphisms in the abstract sense, or do you also mean discussing things like functors? My perspective on this is basically informed by the following: I like category theory a lot. I've chatted with Baez about this on a few occasions and insofar as I need to use algebra, I like the category theoretic formalisms that come along with it. I think if you had students with a lot of mathematical maturity but no prior exposure to abstract algebra (except maybe a rigorous treatment of linear algebra), you could accomplish what you're proposing. To your point, one of my favorite math textbooks is Aluffi's Chapter 0. You're probably familiar with it, but if not: it builds up abstract algebra in a rigorous and modern fashion alongside category theory. However, there are a few caveats here: 1. Aluffi explicitly states it's a textbook for upper level undergrads and preferably graduates. In my experience, when authors say this they actually mean it's appropriate as a year one graduate course. That's not the time to learn abstract algebra for the first time! 2. Aluffi does a great job of covering things like morphisms and categories, but the size of the book is massive. He doesn't have any nontrivial coverage of deeper category theoretic concepts like functors until much later in the book; it's probably far enough in that you couldn't reasonably cover it in a single semester course. 3. I really don't think most math majors would benefit from it. Those who are applied math majors will get questionable benefit from a slower, more comprehensive approach to algebra than a faster approach that lets them get to applications. Moreover, not all pure math majors have the mathematical maturity to approach category theory before grad school. Proofs in traditional abstract algebra are a lot less abstract than category theory, and it's easier to motivate them even if they aren't ultimately as elegant.
- Koshkin 8y ago> knowing that a ring is “like a group...” is useful Turns out, not so much, though. The ring theory bears surprisingly little resemblance to the group theory, to the point that these concepts seem to have nothing to do with each other...
- nerdponx 8y agoExcept that a ring is literally a group under addition? Do you seriously mean to suggest there's no pedagogical value in using groups to teach rings?
- ginnungagap 8y agoThere's actually a big debate between math educators on whether abstract algebra courses should follow a groups first or a rings first approach so it is totally possible to teach rings without appealing to groups. (I'd still argue that both approaches have their advantages and disadvantages and that there can be value in using groups to teach rings though, I just wanted to say it's not as obvious as you might think)
- throwawaymath 8y agoI could be wrong here, but my read of that comment is that they're talking about the structural differences between rings and groups at the research level. Which I guess makes sense, since you're in very different territories if you're talking about something like representation theory of finite groups... Otherwise I agree with you, there's a lot of pedagogical value in combining coverage of algebraic structures.
- dnautics 8y agoYes obviously you need to know what a group is to even begin ring theory but ring theory looks and feels nothing like group theory.
- SatvikBeri 8y agoYup, and I think it's actually a completely rigorous definition – all rings are commutative groups under one operation (often referred to as "addition"), plus another operation ("multiplication"), plus rules for how they interact.
- zozbot123 8y agoThe point of the category-theoretical definition is to explain how these "rules for how they interact" might arise, and in what sense these might be understood as 'minimal' rules. These are not "equivalent" definitions in any real sense, and to think of them as such is arguably missing the whole point of how category theory can be useful here.
- joppy 8y agoOf course I'm not recommending learning ring theory without learning the (usual) definition of a ring. This is absolutely rigorous and useful, and immediately after you learn it you can start playing around with rings, and start proving some interesting theorems. The analogue of this approach in Haskell is probably something like sections 1 and 2 of "Tackling the awkward squad: monadic input/output, concurrency, exceptions, and foreign-language calls in Haskell" [1], which is quite an old paper (from around 2000 or something?). It does not even contain the word "monoid", but instead shows what an IO action is, and how functions like >> and >>= can be used to sequence and thread them. It also provides a lot of context as to why monadic IO exists. After reading this, a new programmer could start playing around with making new IO actions using these operators. After reading about monoid objects, a new programmer is no closer to being able to write a Haskell program. [1]: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/mark.pdf https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/wp-content/uploads/...