4 ms·
> Wayland is impossible to keylog. This is an incorrect assessment of the claim which is, "with Wayland it becomes possible to build a system where application
by Spivak 8y ago
> Wayland is impossible to keylog.
This is an incorrect assessment of the claim which is, "with Wayland it becomes possible to build a system where applications cannot record each-other's events." To the best of my knowledge the only approach with X11 that actually works is running each app with a separate X server. The author points out that being able to register global handlers or programmatically interact with other apps is useful which is why it's possible by asking the compositor nicely. The trick with libinput requires that the system already be pwnd.
Another way of saying the same thing, "you cannot meaningfully sandbox applications that talk to your X server."
> Network Transparency
Is a bad thing and a poor remote desktop solution. Let's say you have a desktop with an Nvidia graphics card and you've installed their drivers. Your laptop is using the OSS Intel drivers. You forward an OpenGL app from your desktop to your laptop -- it will crash. Why? Because Nvidia's libGL expects to talk to a server with Nvidia's GLX extension of the same version.
However, a ton of work is going into getting screencasting and remote desktop working under Wayland in a manner that will let you implement whatever protocol you care to speak on top RDP/VNC.
And VNC currently works on Mutter so I'm not sure why the author is bemoaning it's loss. It's the feature that's getting the most development time right now.
> Multiple clipboards
That's up to the implementor, Wayland had a very general API that's used to exchange data between clients that can be used to implement clipboards in any way the compositor sees fit. Just because GNOME/KDE don't want to maintain it doesn't mean it's not there.
> Restarting ends your session.
If your X server crashes it ends your session too. So this is really an argument that X.org is more stable than Mutter/Kwin. I don't think the devs will argue with that but the point is that they'll get there.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y ago> Multiple clipboards If it's up to the implementer, and two of the biggest options don't do it, then it might as well not exist.
- mbrumlow 8y agoIt's open source. You can add support if you so desire. You can even likely get it pushed upstream if what is done makes sense.
- mcny 8y agoI say good riddance to multiple clipboards. We had to fight hard to get rid of it. It is really tiring having to fight off nonsense unintuitive behavior in software.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoHow are you having to fight it off? If you don't middle click or hit shift-insert, it's invisible. But I find it really useful to trivially move text around with so little friction.
- mcny 8y ago> How are you having to fight it off? If you don't middle click or hit shift-insert, it's invisible. But I find it really useful to trivially move text around with so little friction. There should be just one clipboard by default and by standard. If some people want non-standard behavior, they are welcome to change things in their dot files or whatever but the default behavior should be sensible. I am not saying copy paste should not be available by middle click or shift insert. What I am saying is that the contents of the two clipboards should be the same by default.
- yjftsjthsd-h 8y agoI still don't see what the problem is with leaving them both available by default. You're not harmed by having a second clipboard available if you never use it. As to setting them to the same content by default: I actually tried that once, because in some ways it would be nice to only have one clipboard to think about, but the problem is that as long as you have the feature enabled that automatically copies anything you select, it's incredibly annoying to work with. And I wouldn't want to disable that feature, because it's most of the convenience that makes the select buffer worth having.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoTrusted Solaris had fine grained X Windows security. In the Year 2000... http://www.cse.psu.edu/~trj1/cse544-s10/slides/cse544-lec12-solaris.pdf http://www.cse.psu.edu/~trj1/cse544-s10/slides/cse544-lec12-...
- hedora 8y agoYeah, but it’s not CADT-compliant: https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html https://www.jwz.org/doc/cadt.html