3 ms·
> But I don't see a conceivable way in which discoveries made by studying complex behavior closer to our scale will help solve quantum gravity or dark matter.
by roenxi 8y ago
> But I don't see a conceivable way in which discoveries made by studying complex behavior closer to our scale will help solve quantum gravity or dark matter.
In the main I only see reason and balanced in this post, but this particular statement is a bit risky. Historically, big breakthroughs in the sciences happen when new measurement techniques become available or existing measurement techniques are refined to produce a "significantly" greater level of accuracy.
A breakthrough in our understanding of reality could come from anywhere that anyone pushes the bounds of what we can measure; which admittedly is probably the folk with the budget for a big particle accelerator, but one could imagine a path for almost anybody to make a contribution. One of the take-aways of the whole quantum vs classical business is that just because the evidence seems to be converging on a well respected model doesn't mean that the evidence is actually going to converge.
- jakeinspace 8y agoI definitely agree with you and mathgenius that mathematical techniques and technological progress created while investigating macroscopic behavior may be useful for making breakthroughs in "fundamental" physics. There is certainly precedent for that sort of thing. Perhaps complexity theory will have some significant impact on physics this century, who knows. But it's unclear whether there's anything that pure mathematics or mathematical analogies to the macro world can tell us about how gravity and quantum mechanics are unified, or any of the other big open questions at the bottom.