2 ms·
> What would be the value of that? What problem is that trying to solve that is worth giving up $140 million a year in revenue that’s currently coming almost en
by Nasrudith 8y ago
> What would be the value of that? What problem is that trying to solve that is worth giving up $140 million a year in revenue that’s currently coming almost entirely out of the pockets of lawyers and law firms?
You have it exactly backwards here. There is no need to justify stopping the flow of money but for the flow of money to exist in the first place. There is no right to a business model for such a thing can only end in abject insanity of demanding that it rain so you can sell your umbrellas.
>I’m not sure what you mean by “normalized” in this context
[Database normalization](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_normalization) means ensuring that the data stays consistent across many sources and avoids redundancy. Issues like "There are two postings one for a Allan Smith in New York Court ABC Room A at 3pm on January 2nd, 1993 and one for Alan Smith in New York Court ABC Room A at 3pm on January 2nd, 1993 - which is correct?"
>but Lexis and Westlaw do a ton of additional analysis on top of public cases at their own expense. That information isn’t in PACER.
Then they have their own valid business model to sell their derivative works to supplement the public data that anyone else can get for free.
- rayiner 8y ago> You have it exactly backwards here. There is no need to justify stopping the flow of money but for the flow of money to exist in the first place. There is no right to a business model for such a thing can only end in abject insanity of demanding that it rain so you can sell your umbrellas. No, you’re demanding the government give umbrellas away for free because people have a right to be protected from the rain. The government isn’t stopping you from distributing documents you got on PACER. It’s charging you for access to PACER itself. > Issues like "There are two postings one for a Allan Smith in New York Court ABC Room A at 3pm on January 2nd, 1993 and one for Alan Smith in New York Court ABC Room A at 3pm on January 2nd, 1993 - which is correct?" PACER just stores free-form PDF files. There is some metadata, but the substance of your example above would be in the PDF. > Then they have their own valid business model to sell their derivative works to supplement the public data that anyone else can get for free. That’s what they do. The original court opinions are free on PACER.
- comex 8y agoThe opinions are free. The rest of the filings, which you need if you want information about a case which has not yet been decided, or if you want a fuller picture of what's going on in any case, are not. Personally, I have no idea whether it's possible to do meaningful data analysis on PACER data, so I'm not necessarily arguing against your original point. But as a non-lawyer who sometimes gets interested in particular court cases, I find PACER fees obnoxious. Partly because the fees force me to think about whether I actually need a particular piece of information, which is so alien to the normal way I browse anything on the Web. And partly because the fees are the reason I have to actually deal with PACER's 90's-style interface: if all PACER data were free, I'm sure there would be at least one free website mirroring that data with a nicer interface.