3 ms·
The concept of precedent in itself disagrees with you there - it isn't just a techie thing because a fundamental principle of law is consistency in application.
by Nasrudith 8y ago
The concept of precedent in itself disagrees with you there - it isn't just a techie thing because a fundamental principle of law is consistency in application. The value may not be financial per say (nobody gets rich directly out of ensuring equal application of the law) but it has a major impact upon quality of life. While it may be used as an excuse to avoid thinking there is a value to precedent in itself in making the laws predictable and better in bounds of certainty.
Gathering the data of trials and judgement can prove when something isn't working and prove how things are actually working in the field better than even the best rhetorician. The question of 'should we be doing something' is separate from data.
But being able to get the cases together and point out that 'minimum/maximum sentences are constraining judges and juries since in 70% of the cases they note that they would go with lower/higher but they are constrained from it'. It can point out real problems with inequality in execution or corruption. Civic hacking is meant for accountability essentially to show how the system is or isn't working. Which is part of why resistance to it is so worrying.
- rayiner 8y agoThat data is already out there. Almost the entire corpus of federal cases is available in data dumps online. I’ve never seen anything interesting done with it. Don’t confuse my opposition to techno-optimism with opposition to accountability. The issue is not that we shouldn’t have accountability. It’s that there is already a ton of data out there, and civic hackers have had approximately zero impact with it. Because for the most part what you actually need is carefully controlled studies from real institutions, not “civic hacking.” Civic hacking is the techie version of “raising awareness.”