2 ms·
In "The Master and His Emissary", a (usually described as deeply flawed but fascinating) book by Iain McGilchrist about brain organization, the author had an al
by ncmncm 8y ago
In "The Master and His Emissary", a (usually described as deeply flawed but fascinating) book by Iain McGilchrist about brain organization, the author had an alternative interpretation to address the essential timing problem of JJ's notion, where events around the Iliad are several thousand years too late for the process he describes.
The fascination with JJ's idea is not about his theory, it is about the problem he tried to solve, and that we still have not solved. He offered one idea, and supported it as well as he could with what he had, but discarding his idea takes you no closer to a solution.
Note that the events of the Iliad are around the beginning of the Iron Age, near the time of what historians call The Catastrophe, of c. 1190 BC when all the coastal cities around the Mediterranean (except in Egypt) were sacked, and written records dry up for four centuries. The Iliad was written down sometime after the end of this period, coincidentally around the time coins were first minted. Civilization had already existed for 2000+ years, and had money all along, just no actual currency. The Great Pyramids were already ancient, but still much more impressive-looking than today, because their white facing had not yet been stripped off to build mosques of. But I Digress.