3 ms·
To say "Swahili speakers don't understand English" is already to assume that Swahili is not a dialect of English, and therefore a circular argument. Or else you
by kazinator 8y ago
To say "Swahili speakers don't understand English" is already to assume that Swahili is not a dialect of English, and therefore a circular argument. Or else you would have to admit that Swahili speakers do understand an English dialect: their own!
Take someone who is trained in Clojure programming and nothing else; which Lisp's code can they understand that is not derived from Clojure, like ClojureScript?
Basically, the criterion for a "dialect" is mutual intelligibility. A language which is an island isn't a dialect of anything. Two languages that are not mutually intelligible are not dialects.
Lisps are dialects which share a mutual intelligibility formed by the core that comes from the ancient Lisp. They are based on the same or very similar core concepts and use the same names for them.
- coldtea 8y ago>To say "Swahili speakers don't understand English" is already to assume that Swahili is not a dialect of English, and therefore a circular argument. Or else you would have to admit that Swahili speakers do understand an English dialect: their own! That's not really a counter-argument by absurdity to my argument, as it's also valid. To say "Swahili speakers don't understand English" indeed already assumes that Swahili is not a dialect of English. When one says "Swahili speakers don't understand English" they don't make an argument -- they make a statement of fact. Now, one could argue that the fact that Swahili is different than English is well established, and needs no further arguments (as people will already be familiar with it and accept it). But regarding whether Clojure is or is not a dialect of Lisp, I don't think that's the case.