5 ms·
Herd immunity is immensely important and an underrated benefity in modern society. We lived near a large religious community in Ohio that does not practice vac
by tomrod 8y ago
Herd immunity is immensely important and an underrated benefity in modern society.
We lived near a large religious community in Ohio that does not practice vaccination while my children were too small to be fully vaccinated. Whenever measles or other outbreaks would occur, we had legitimate fears for our children's health.
I wonder if the benefits of non-compliance were offset with more certain negative impacts if more people would be vaccinated. Something like a tax levied for not being vaccinated set at compensating the ongoing care for people who can't (rather than choose to not) be vaccinated and get sick with things herd immunity would prevent.
- ajmurmann 8y agoI'm terrified by the idea that people like that are allowed to indoctrinate children's mins from early age on. Just because a child had the misfortune to be born to a crazy person shouldn't allow them to mess them up for good.
- mikekchar 8y agoI don't know what the rules are for medicine, etc, but for education here in Japan teachers often trump parents. When I was working at the high school here, I can't tell you the number of times parents were brought in so that the teachers could yell at them for doing a poor job. The teachers even go to the house to ensure that the home environment is acceptable for the child. Personally, I like the system and if I had kids I would happily raise them here. However, I've talked to many expat parents who despise it and believe that the state should never be able to tell them how to raise their children. There are good arguments on both sides and probably there are balance points where it mostly works (and sometimes fails spectacularly) all across the spectrum.
- acomjean 8y agoThere is an currently an outbreak of Measles in Washington. Yet the anti-vaxers are still out in force, against any move by the government requiring vaxination.[1] People with children too young to be vacinated are running scared[2]. its odd. I really wonder sometimes what is driving the anti vax movement. It seems like something that exists with nothing for anyone to gain. I'm all for questioning things, but it seems people aren't able to make the rational decisions and are endangering others. [1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2019/02/08/washington-measles-outbreak-draws-crowd-hearing-vaccine-law https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2019/02/08/washington-... [2]https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/it-will-take-off-like-a-wildfire-the-unique-dangers-of-the-washington-state-measles-outbreak/2019/02/06/cfd5088a-28fa-11e9-b011-d8500644dc98_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/it-wi...
- mindslight 8y agoIt's a great thing that the anti-vaxers are coming out in force. Ideally on a calm day. What a lot of people seem to be missing is that the anti-vaxxers are actually pro-science. They are sacrificing to reproduce a result that the rest of us consider settled. The quicker they're able to draw a conclusion from their experiment, the better.
- colemickens 8y agoIt's a good thing that these people's young children may contract violent whooping cough, or may die a miserable death, because their parents have freedom? It's good thing that others who can't vaccinate or otherwise benefit from herd immunity are getting sick while we let these parents play out their experiment? I suspect you didn't mean that, but I think we need to take this more seriously, again, per the grandparent, given the broader public health risk that this movement plays, particularly outside its adherents.
- tapland 8y agoWooping cough vaccines have full effect for about 10 years. Adults get it, but a lot don't consider wooping cough since they assume the vaccines last forever.
- mindslight 8y agoWhat you have said is indeed the direct implication of what I said. And I did mean to say what I said. I've got to wonder if the sensationalist panic of our times isn't simply due to people not being able to accept mild sarcasm in written form. Humor is a coping mechanism - read some horrible less-mediated truth, shake your head, sigh, and build some consensus based around calming rather than outrage. What I am plainly sure of is that getting more and more worked up ("take this more seriously") about the actions of people I can't control isn't going to solve the problem either.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 8y agoherd immunity, very low density population count pick one
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tasty_freeze 8y agoIt isn't just young children at risk. Some fraction of the people who were immunized are still at risk of catching the disease. Getting an immunization doesn't guarantee immunity. There is a fundamental trade-off at play: make the immunization shot too strong and more people get harmed; make it too weak and fewer people actually get immunity. The funny thing about the anti-vax crowd is they have opted to turn the dial to the maximum, and most dangerous, setting: use a full strength virus in order to gain future immunity.
- tetra_proxy 8y agoImmunizations wear off over time that's why we get boosters, and even having the virus doesn't guarantee lifelong immunity. I had chicken pox as a child and recently was hospitalized for chicken pox as an adult twenty some years later.