3 ms·
> Something doesn't have to be necessarily expressible into a single, unambiguous universal formula to be made illegal. It doesn't have to be expressed with a
by paulddraper 8y ago
> Something doesn't have to be necessarily expressible into a single, unambiguous universal formula to be made illegal.
It doesn't have to be expressed with a precise mathematical formula, but it does need to be expressed with a clear legal formula.
Otherwise, people cannot know whether or not their actions are legal, and the law becomes a fearsome weapon in the hands of its interpreters.
---
EDIT: I'm not claiming it's impossible for such a rule to be formulated in this case; I merely point out that clarity is absolutely necessary.
- perfmode 8y agoThe law has been a fearsome weapon in the hands of its interpreters since 1776. Stop acting like this is new. We need to reform our broken system.
- nubbins 8y agoIts just not possible in general to know a priori the legality of 100% of your actions. Companies have entire compliance departments to attempt this and still cant always get it right. There are tons of grey areas and edge cases so what actually happens is the relevant authorities and advocates get together after the fact to figure out the legality. I don’t know how anyone would propose to write a legal code that covers 100% of circumstances and doesn’t need human interpretaion but I feel like it it would be akin to the problem of general AI.
- paulddraper 8y ago> Its just not possible in general to know a priori the legality of 100% of your actions. To the degree that this fact is true, the law is broken.