4 ms·
I have a Facebook friend who is fairly active in the anti-vaccine community. I don’t know much about the science, but the one thing she has posted that has conc
by gnicholas 8y ago
I have a Facebook friend who is fairly active in the anti-vaccine community. I don’t know much about the science, but the one thing she has posted that has concerned me is that insurers pay doctors significant sums (tens of thousands) if the super-majority or their patients are vaccinated on a certain schedule. She has posted printouts that allege this, and I’ve not seen any arguments that dispute this claim (there are lots of people disputing other claims of hers, just not this one).
Does anyone know if this is true? It resonated with me because when we were vaccinating our baby, we asked if we could slow down the vaccination schedule and spread out the shots a little. The doctor was very strongly against any spacing, even though she couldn’t articulate why. If she’s being measured/compensated based on having patients vaccinated on-schedule as my friend claims is the case, this would explain her reaction.
Note: we fully vaccinated our child, despite her having an adverse reaction to the chicken pox vaccine (which we never had as kids, since at that time everyone just got the chicken pox).
- gwbas1c 8y agoCompletely false. Doctors push vaccines because they work very well, and don't want to see you get sick. (I married a pediatrician.) Any financial incentives that exist are because insurance companies are incentivised to have everyone vaccinated for very obvious reasons. If you don't understand what the obvious reasons are, think about how much it costs to take care of someone hospitalized, versus the cost of a shot.
- kingnight 8y agoHaving taken schedules of medicine myself, what resonates with me is the balance between strength and consistency of whatever the medicine is supposed to do. Think about alleviating pain. You want to take as much pain reliever as you can to take effect but not too much at once to overdo it, but you should continue over period of hours to sustain its fever / pain reducing effect.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Confiks 8y agoSounds like general doctor's resistance against picking another schedule, even if it can't be articulated well. See [1] for considerations among pediatricians. Insurance companies may indeed pay more or less for 'well designed' vaccinations programs, and may incentivize vaccination in general in some locales as a long-term cost reduction program [2]. [1] https://seattlemamadoc.seattlechildrens.org/pediatricians-conditional-comfort-with-alternative-vaccine-schedules/ https://seattlemamadoc.seattlechildrens.org/pediatricians-co... [2] https://vaxopedia.org/2017/09/24/that-3-million-vaccine-bonus-for-pediatricians/ https://vaxopedia.org/2017/09/24/that-3-million-vaccine-bonu...
- c22 8y agoFor what it's worth, I typed "vaccination schedule rationale" into a search engine and received many interesting results, several which did not seem to have been paid for by the insurance industry.
- brownbat 8y agoFinancial incentives don't make something automatically wrong. Google provides this explanation about a Blue Cross incentive program similar to what you describe that sounds modest, benign, and completely justified: https://vaxopedia.org/2017/09/24/that-3-million-vaccine-bonus-for-pediatricians/ https://vaxopedia.org/2017/09/24/that-3-million-vaccine-bonu... My insurance program gives incentives for people to achieve a healthy weight, quit smoking, and get regular checkups. I understand the financial incentives, but presumably a couple people in the firm think they might be helping people too. Even insurers can't be sinister all the time.
- JshWright 8y agoI'm happy to believe they're sinister 100% of the time. What they clearly aren't is stupid. If they are spending money to incentivize behavior, it's because that is in their financial best interest. In this case, it just so happens that their best interest (not wanting to pay for care) aligns with mine (not wanting any more care than I have to have).
- tssva 8y agoI don't know if this is true or not but either way why would anyone want to refute this? Insurance companies paying doctors to make sure patients are vaccinated according to the recommended schedule is a ringing endorsement of vaccination. Insurance companies would in effect be saying with their wallet that vaccinations are safe and effective. Effective enough that paying doctors ten's of thousands is cheaper than paying for the increased costs of care resulting from a significant number of patients not being vaccinated. Since insurance companies would also bear a significant part of the cost of care for patients that were negatively affected by vaccines, this also implies that the rate of and impact of negative effects from vaccination are low.
- JshWright 8y agoThere are lots of examples of programs where payers (insurance companies, medicare, etc) pay doctors who are meeting various measures. This could be anything form ensuring patients who are at risk for various diseases (cancer, diabetes, etc) get screened for those diseases, to making sure high blood pressure is well controlled, to making sure patients are getting vaccinated. Check out CPC+ as just one example. There is nothing inherently bad about these incentive models (they are trying to address a number of issues with the current fee-for-service model). If anything, they are proof of the efficacy of these actions. The "evil" insurance company's primary goal is spending less money on care, so if they're willing to pay doctors to vaccinate at the recommended rate, then clearly it's in their financial interest to do so (i.e. vaccinated patients cost the insurance company less money, which is a pretty good proxy for "vaccinated patients have fewer health issues"). Can you articulate why you would want to "slow down" the vaccination schedule? The current guidelines are based on a significant body of research. What evidence are you basing your decision on?
- blackoil 8y agoThis should be a pro-vaccination point. Insurance companies can only be benefited from this if they make short/long term return on it. i.e. people fall less sick reducing insurance claim. Isn't this what vaccines are for? Or, is there some theory that companies are in bed with NSA/Illuminati to make the world impotent?
- wvenable 8y agoThe US is not the only country in the world -- all my vaccinations were free and there was no profit motive built into the system for it.
- JshWright 8y agoPresumably your physician was still paid, and there are plenty of programs in various countries that compensate physicians for following best practices like this (this is generally a good thing).
- wvenable 8y agoMy physician is paid for any sort of checkup. I'm sure every one of them would happily poison their patients for the visit fee. /s
- HillRat 8y agoThe CDC schedule is designed to minimize the risk of infants contracting preventable diseases during periods when they are highly vulnerable. In addition, clinical research and experience is based on the recommended schedule, so once you’re off the schedule you’re in terra incognita. Since research hasn’t shown any clinical benefit to going off-schedule, and because of infants’ extreme vulnerability, pediatricians aren’t generallly going to volunteer to change vaccination frequency, as it would contravene the patient’s best interests (medically speaking). As far as payers are concerned, your insurance may incentivize certain physicians based on overall (covered) patient immunization rates; this isn’t anything new, going back at least a few decades. From the insurance perspective, immunizations are a financial firewall — vaccinated kids means fewer seriously ill (read: expensive) kids. However, there’s no evidence that financial incentives materially change vaccination rates, just the quality of documentation (less of an issue with EMRs these days).
- mindslight 8y ago> we asked if we could slow down the vaccination schedule and spread out the shots a little. The doctor was very strongly against any spacing, even though she couldn’t articulate why You aren't wrong to question, because most professionals seem to just apply a rubric deductively rather than spending thought analyzing every situation. But if you would seriously like to understand / check her advice, then you need to do research on this specific subject and come up with your own informed opinion. Likely there is some debate in the medical community on timing, and the doctor either made that decision and doesn't seem the need to revisit it or is simply following a colleague. What you can't do is take her lack of explanation as if she's hiding something, and then backpropagate and conclude that she must be doing it for nefarious reasons. That is essentially equating laziness with malice.
- gnicholas 8y ago> What you can't do is take her lack of explanation as if she's hiding something, and then backpropagate and conclude that she must be doing it for nefarious reasons. That is essentially equating laziness with malice Note that I didn't do that. I asked a question, which is whether anyone has information on whether such payments are made.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- colemickens 8y agoThis is what I hate the most about this anti-vax thing. They've gotten so much publicity and are so wide-spread, that even people who know vaccines don't cause autism, wind up getting trapped into this game where they think they have to compromise for the anti-vax viewpoint. All they have to do is throw handwavey bullshit out there until enough people doubt and do stupid made-up stuff like spacing out the vaccines for some unknown, unmeasurable benefit. There are people in my state, in the "best country on Earth", dying from preventable diseases because of OTHER PEOPLES' pseudo-scientific crap and "beliefs". I just can't take it. When are we going to drop what we're doing and pour the billions we need into public education? - funding, reform, curriculum, emphasis on personal finance and logical reasoning skills. Pick a topic - climate change, flat earth, vaccines/autism, all of this irrationality starts with education. Also, insurance companies go out of their way to incentivize and encourage proactive health measures, especially for younger groups; given all credible scientific research and data, and barring some other weird conspiracy, it seems reasonable to think they're encouraging vaccines because they keep people from getting preventable diseases and suffering miserable deaths.
- brandonmenc 8y ago> When are we going to drop what we're doing and pour the billions we need into public education? Anecdotal, but most of the anti-vaxxers I know are relatively highly educated.
- tphan 8y agoAnti-vaccination isn't exclusively an American phenomenon. It just seems like it because most commenters would be Americans or foreigners who live in bubbles. I remember in high school in Australia about a decade ago, there was one kid who was said innoculations were akin to "injecting garbage into your bloodstream". I also frequently give blood in Australia and there are also more and more warnings about measles and stuff (interestingly regarding neighbourhoods that tend to vote very progressive). Anecdotal evidence, however!
- madhadron 8y agoI've heard the spacing idea from a number of people, saying it's somehow easier on the kid's system. It doesn't really work that way. All you do by spacing it out is take your kid to the doctor's office to be jabbed by needles more times than necessary and expose them for longer to preventable diseases.
- brandonmenc 8y ago> chicken pox vaccine (which we never had as kids, since at that time everyone just got the chicken pox) If you get chicken pox, your chances of getting shingles later in life is much higher. It is not pleasant. Also, chicken pox can be deadly. That's why we have a vaccine now.