3 ms·
> How is this different than taking a picture of someone? The image is owned by the photographer, not the subject(s) according to current laws. The photographe
by bsder 8y ago
> How is this different than taking a picture of someone? The image is owned by the photographer, not the subject(s) according to current laws.
The photographer may own the image, but the subject may also need to sign a release for the photographer to monetize.
> if I meet someone on the street, and record their name, the conversation we had, and the location where I met them, and their phone number, have I “taken their data”?
> Do they have the right to demand that I not record that information?
In some US states, yes. Many states have what is called "two party consent" and you cannot record a conversation with a device unless both parties agree.
> Or is it only if I do this at a scale beyond which humans are not capable, and store it digitally, is that what makes this illegal?
There are many different factors. However, one of the big ones I would put forth is if I don't ever interact with your service and you still have a profile on me.
My friends tag pictures on Facebook. This means that Facebook now has a profile on me that I did NOT consent to. What is MY recourse?
- paulddraper 8y ago> What is MY recourse? Your first statement would imply that the photographer has some responsibility to gain consent for the picture and its use.
- bsder 8y agoAnd what about the other 30 people taking selfies whose background I am in. Those people didn't ask me because they didn't need to. They don't know me; I don't know them; we're not going to interact. Facebook, however, is coordinating all those pictures, their GPS coordinates, their tags, and working out everybody in them. I did not give anyone permission for that. Yet I don't have a way to stop it.
- bryan_w 8y agoYou can wear a mask