3 ms·
The rules always get written to control the big companies like FB, despite the fact the laws effect the whole marketplace of thousands of companies of different
by dmix 8y ago
The rules always get written to control the big companies like FB, despite the fact the laws effect the whole marketplace of thousands of companies of different sizes. But big companies like FB have enough lawyers and influence and never really change. Meanwhile the laws cripple all sorts of harmless small-medium sized companies, including potential future better competitors to FB. And the laws stay law for decades before they get fixed, if ever.
There are countless examples of this in other industries. Some of the laws following the 2008 financial crisis are a good example which reduced the market place of hundreds of small banks who couldn’t operate with the new rules and further solidified the positions of the 5 mega banks. So much for ending “too big to fail”.
Idealism of “what should be done” meets reality of always historically ends up happening. If you’re interested in this topic Thomas Sowell included a hundred examples of well intentioned laws having the opposite effect and making problems either worse or stopping the one problem and generating far worse ones (usually after a period of time when every claims the regulation a success and moves on, before the reality of the situation reveals itself).
https://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Poverty-Politics-Gordon-Tullock/dp/0631151133 https://www.amazon.com/Wealth-Poverty-Politics-Gordon-Tulloc...
- fzeroracer 8y agoLet's say that your argument is true: That large companies are effectively immune to the law and any type of regulation we pass would simply wash right over them. I don't buy into this one bit considering my personal experience with GDPR at a larger company, but for the sake of argumentation let's follow that logic. If companies are too large to be affected by law, then the only recourse is for the government to step in and break their monopoly. A company that is unaffected by laws will also have extreme leverage in the free market and have the strength to smother those smaller small-medium sized companies you claim are competitors to FB. It would seem illogical that a company would have the lawyers and influence to ignore regulations, but not be willing to use that same influence to kill competitors.
- StellarTabi 8y ago> The rules always get written to control the big companies like FB, despite the fact the laws effect the whole marketplace of thousands of companies of different sizes. Yup, and this is why campaign finance reform is so important.
- Apocryphon 8y ago> There are countless examples of this in other industries. But do you have an actual example of this happening in tech? And beyond that, a series of examples showing this to be a systemic problem? Because high-tech has long been a Wild West with little regulation, and many many firms have been built upon finding ways to dodge existing regulation and social conventions. They will likely be fine.