2 ms·
> Beyond some point even actual violence is OK. For behaving like a jerk? That's bonkers.
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> Beyond some point even actual violence is OK.
For behaving like a jerk? That's bonkers.
- coldtea 8y agoReally? I'm pretty sure most resort to actual violence after the jerkish behavior extends a threshold. Where do you cut the "jerk behavior" threshold? Someone skipping a queue? Smoking in a closed office? It could get way worse... How about someone hitting badly on your wife with you and your kids present and no taking no for an answer (and them knowing it you're married?)
- chrisseaton 8y agoNo you can only use physical violence in defence of yourself or others against imminent physical harm. I think in the US you can also use it against someone in your home (presumably because by the time in your home you are otherwise defenceless.) Anything else is you just assaulting someone and puts you in the wrong. The law doesn't allow for 'they were winding me up' as a reason to assault someone. I can't believe anyone would think violence was warranted for skipping a queue or speaking to someone in a way you didn't like.
- coldtea 8y ago>No you can only use physical violence in defence of yourself or others against imminent physical harm. That's legally. I wasn't talking about legally -- but about what people will actually do beyond some point, legal implications or not.
- macintux 8y agoAnd “OK” is how you described violence in the absence of a genuine threat, which is not an objective statement of “what people will actually do” but a subjective endorsement.