4 ms·
The real problem is when you can't reasonably choose to do business with someone else and move on, as they are free to do with you. Something I learned the har
by reaperducer 8y ago
The real problem is when you can't reasonably choose to do business with someone else and move on, as they are free to do with you.
Something I learned the hard way when I first started out in business is to never make your business dependent on a single entity.
Whether it's a supplier, or a publisher, or a telco, or whatever. They are all single points of failure, and unless you're a huge business, one failure can be all that's needed to take you down, too.
Yes, Google Play is effectively the only way to publish an Android program. But it's also a single point of failure, which is why until there is no longer a mobile program duopoly, I don't invest in app companies.
- sbov 8y ago> Something I learned the hard way when I first started out in business is to never make your business dependent on a single entity. Seems impossible. Assuming you're an internet business, how did you make your business not dependent upon your domain registrar?
- quickthrower2 8y agoOut of the myriad registrars, you can pick a good one, or at least one that lets you transfer out easily.
- calabin 8y agoI can't remember the exact details of the story I read here on HN, but there was a case of some SaaS company that had this exact issue. Fortunately they were able to spread the word to temporarily use a backup domain on a different registrar via social media until the issue was resolved. If anyone reading this remembers that story, I would very much appreciate a link.
- tomjohnneill 8y agoI don't have a link, but pretty sure it was Zoho
- lenomad 8y agoIt was Zoho. Their registrar took down their main domain after a few phishing reports. https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/24/zoho-pulled-offline-after-phishing-complaints-ceo-says/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/09/24/zoho-pulled-offline-after-...
- davchana 8y agoJotform & Zoho had similar issues in the past.
- reaperducer 8y agohow did you make your business not dependent upon your domain registrar? It wasn't an internet business, so I didn't have to deal with those kinds of perils. But more to your point, I knew a guy who put one on .com, one on .info, one on a county tld. Advertising material rotated through the three. His logic was that it didn't really matter what address was advertised because people just hit a search engine for the brand name. I haven't spoken to him in years, so I don't know how it worked out.
- progval 8y ago> Advertising material rotated through the three. His logic was that it didn't really matter what address was advertised because people just hit a search engine for the brand name. This is a great idea, thanks for sharing
- emiliobumachar 8y agoSeems effective, but I assume he took a huge SEO penalty, possibly without being aware of it. The search relevance of the site got divided by all the domains.
- londons_explore 8y agoGoogle at least is smart enough to identify alias domains, and you can even tell it how to behave in the search console
- gregmac 8y agoTypically, a registrar is not irreplaceable. They could terminate your account so you'd have to transfer to another registrar, but unless their TOS says they can seize your domain they shouldn't be able to completely block you. Even then you have the ability to sue then if they break the contract terms. This is in contrast to the app store gatekeepers, where there are effectively two, each serving a non-overlapping chuck of market, and you can't shop around for better terms or an alternative. Not an ideal situation if something happens with your registrar, of course, but at least there is some possible recourse. The risk of this leading to your business closing is significantly lower.
- bitreality 8y agoThat is precisely the problem with the current landscape for online businesses. Nearly every step of the way there is a single entity that you need to work with, or you are toast. The biggest one lately comes down to marketplaces and payment processing. For example, if you are running a business selling a physical product, and you are banned from: - Amazon - PayPal Your business is dead. It usually comes down to exposure and payment processing. Some businesses can gain exposure through a variety of channels. But most businesses get the majority of their customers through a small list of channels. That can be Facebook Ads, SEO, Forums, etc. If you wake up one day and Google de-lists you from organic search, and the majority of your traffic was from SEO, you're dead. You can try refocusing and investing in other channels, but the majority of your potential new customers probably use one or two channels to find your service. So unless you are the only person offering said service, they'll just go to a competitor. These companies like Amazon, Google, Paypal, Facebook, Apple have become gatekeepers. Try and do any type of e-commerce without using the above services. Good luck buddy! Many businesses boil down to 1-3 of the above. Losing access to one can be all it takes to go from a highly successful company to a doomed company. And these services will ban you on ToS violations, without ever explaining what part of the ToS you violated. The implication from such a ban is that your business, your livelihood, your life's pursuit is instantly crippled or dead. The implication to them is nothing.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoDo you avoid companies that take only Master/Visa who are happy to prevent certain businesses receiving payment? All internet business that needs Google search to get visits? 5% bing doesn't really cut it. I mean it's easy to say and believe that you should avoid those single points of failure, but the real, practical landscape often includes many of them.
- lugg 8y agoGP stated they avoid investing in them. i.e. the risk profile doesn't align with their I vestment strategy. What you're bringing up is kind of obvious but also irrelevant. I'd ask what businesses do they invest in and figure out if those businesses are really less risky. I would posit they are probably not. The risk of having amazon Google or apple being a single point of failure is abysmally small compared to all the other risks out there.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoHardly irrelevant as if that's the strategy, you're going to be left with few businesses to start or invest in. From a practical point of view even a single office site may be such a single point of failure. There are many practical single or narrow points of failure a bootstrapped startup or small business may encounter. The real risk to most starting out business is being seen as irrelevant - by the potential customers or search, whether app store or Google.
- SiVal 8y agoI agree, but this is the equivalent of choosing not to walk through dangerous neighborhoods. At a personal level, where you don't make the world but have to deal with reality as it is, this is wise if you have the option. Save yourself if you can. But at the same time, you should also support policy changes that you believe will make the dangerous neighborhoods safe. Save others, too, if you can. Anything that makes a neighborhood "dangerous" should be removed as long as it's not simply replaced by something equally dangerous. If a market or medium is too dangerous to enter because there is no realistic alternative to submitting to the 800-lb gorilla, the gorilla's ability to threaten rather than compete must be eliminated.
- megaman8 8y agoMost media companies effectively have this as a single point of failure: Google Search. And, it's not from lack of trying to diversify. Countless businesses must depend on it, espcially media and content based businesses. I of some very large media companies in existance for over 10 years, and they still get over 50% of their traffic directly from Google. If google decided to ban them, their multi-million dollar business would dissappear almost overnight.