3 ms·
The piece of the puzzle that you're missing is that people use accounts for fraud, and if they find out why an account got banned, they'll know which behavior t
by crazygringo 8y ago
The piece of the puzzle that you're missing is that people use accounts for fraud, and if they find out why an account got banned, they'll know which behavior triggered it and will learn to avoid that behavior in the rest of their accounts and future accounts.
It sucks, but automating sharing reasons for flagged actions will be self-defeating.
Ultimately it needs to be reviewed by a person at the company who is equipped to judge the situation with more intelligence and discretion to determine if it's really fraud or not.
- megous 8y ago> The piece of the puzzle that you're missing is that people use accounts for fraud, and if they find out why an account got banned, they'll know which behavior triggered it and will learn to avoid that behavior in the rest of their accounts and future accounts. Compliance is the goal, no? How's it self-defeating if you ban non-compliant behavior and only way around it is to basically get more compliant with the rules? How will you get compliance if you don't share details with clueless violators, so they can avoid the mistakes in the future? That seems self-defeating, because this gets rid of clueless, but potentially valuable developers.
- crankylinuxuser 8y ago> The piece of the puzzle that you're missing is that people commit crime, and if they find out why they got in trouble with the law, they'll know which behavior triggered it and will learn to avoid that behavior. > It sucks, but automating sharing reasons for illegal actions will be self-defeating. Yes I changed your text from corporate "illegal" to government "illegal". We wouldn't let THAT fly in a court of law. We have rules on that, like the 4th and 5th amendment. Right to have the charges read before them; right to face their accuser; right to a fair trial; right to be secure in their houses/papers/effects So what are the charges? "We will not tell you what you did." Who's the accuser who said I did the thing? "It cannot be in the courtroom. It is an algorithm. Secure in your effects? You waived them (unilaterally) in dealing with a monopoly. Too bad, soo sad. Fair trial? SURELY YOU JEST!