3 ms·
The problem with "bullshit jobs" isn't necessarily that they're completely unnecessary, it's that they lie many layers of indirection and specialization away fr
by philwelch 8y ago
The problem with "bullshit jobs" isn't necessarily that they're completely unnecessary, it's that they lie many layers of indirection and specialization away from the delivery of value. For example, receptionists and secretaries (two rapidly dying professions, BTW) don't just "serve to make their superiors feel important", they significantly improve the productivity of the people they assist. These jobs are literally an Econ 101 example of comparative advantage.
But even those examples are blatantly obvious to anyone who actually works with a receptionist or secretary. Other examples are less so, but effective organizations try to do a good job of showing people how their work fits into the bigger picture. If you're on an assembly line all day drilling three holes into a sheet of steel, by default you're going to feel alienated. The solution to that is to say, no, you're not just drilling three holes into a sheet of steel, you're helping to build a car. And if you do your job well, you're going to build the best cars in the world. And if you have ideas about how to improve the part of the manufacturing process that you're personally involved in, we will continuously improve the process based on your feedback. And so on and so forth. Alienation happens, but it doesn't have to, and when it does happen, it usually either leads to or coincides with poor results. Those solutions I mentioned didn't come from academics or revolutionaries; they came from engineers and industrialists.
Pointless jobs do exist, but most of these jobs exist for reasons like "it's hard to efficiently coordinate large organizations", "sometimes game theory leads to shitty outcomes", and "some people are either con artists or cranks".