3 ms·
If you look at what ex-prosecutors say, many of them think it's clearly enough to bring charges, but it's not clear cut case in the court. The blackmail attemp
by nabla9 8y ago
If you look at what ex-prosecutors say, many of them think it's clearly enough to bring charges, but it's not clear cut case in the court.
The blackmail attempt happened during ongoing negotiations with over potential legal claims against one another. The defense will argue that they were playing hardball and using dirty and distasteful tactics that is still legal. Prosecutors will argue that this goes far beyond it.
It's weird that Pecker and the company lawyers choose take the risk. They are in no-prosecution agreement with federal prosecutors under conditions that the firm can't do any crimes in next two years or the deal is off.
- ncallaway 8y ago> ... many of them think it's clearly enough to bring charges, but it's not clear cut case in the court. > They are in no-prosecution agreement with federal prosecutors under conditions that the firm can't do any crimes in next two years or the deal is off These two facts are crazy to me, because the prosecution doesn't have to win in court to tear up the deal. The prosecution generally just has to show that they made a determination in good faith that a crime was committed. So there is a _much_ lower bar to tear up the deal if the prosecution thinks something smells criminal. I just don't get why you would possibly risk the immunity deal for this. The reward doesn't seem worth the risk at all.
- jaxn 8y agoMaybe they are in the habit of doing things like this and getting away with it?
- rubyfan 8y agoThat’s my guess why they were blackmailing in the first place. He already knew they were illegally obtained and they knew that would blow their deal with the government. They weren’t taking any additional risk, more like playing a risky game they thought they could win. Maybe they thought the richest married man in the world wouldn’t want to deal with the embarrassment of having his dirty laundry shared with the world. Seems like he called their bluff.
- awakeasleep 8y agoIt's not weird if you think of AMI as a fundamentally predatory organization. They don't know how to operate outside that frame. A leopard knows it can't afford to get kicked in the head by a zebra. But hunting is the way it evolved to live. Even if it has a close call or gets injured, it can't afford to stop hunting. AEI had a close call with the deferred prosecution. Im guessing the organizational culture or business pressures do not allow the company to alter course significantly for years required.
- jchallis 8y agoThey have been playing high stakes poker for a long time and are used to bluffing with embarrassing information . Their mistake was to think that would deter Bezos.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> I just don't get why you would possibly risk the immunity deal for this. Because the investigation they are trying to kill is bound to uncover serious crimes that are not covered by the non-prosecution agreement that in aggregate present much more serious exposure. I mean, that would be a rational motive, at least.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- elliekelly 8y ago> The blackmail attempt happened during ongoing negotiations with over potential legal claims against one another. This is where AMI's argument falls apart. 1. The photos were somehow acquired without permission. Meaning Bezos and/or Sanchez were victims of some sort of (likely illegal) invasion of privacy. 2. AMI is threatening to publish the photos despite not having permission to reproduce the photos from the copyright holders (Bezos/Sanchez). 3. AMI is making this threat on the dubious legal grounds of "fair use" by claiming that nude photos of a businessman's girlfriend are "newsworthy" because that somehow speaks to his business judgment. 4. Aren't seeking a monetary settlement but instead are asking the victims to (i) sign a legal document stating they have not in fact been victims of a crime at all[1] and (ii) make a public statement that is both against their interests and untrue. That is _far_ from a good faith negotiation and it was only one way. AMI has no claim to release against Bezos or Sanchez, they're only offering to not do what they legally can't do anyway: publish pictures they do not own without permission. [1] From proposed settlement terms: "AM affirms that it undertook no electronic eavesdropping in connection with its reporting and has no knowledge of such conduct."
- graeme 8y agoI'm confused on the timeline. Was Bezos actually negotiating with AMI, or did AMI make the threat and claim to be negotiating? I have trouble imagining that Bezos was actively considering ending washington post coverage against the enquirer or negotiating as such.
- berberous 8y agoI think there was a little bit of rope-a-dope going on. Bezos was acting like he was interested in negotiating to get AMI to put this stuff in writing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]