3 ms·
Of course. "We quoted Mein Kampf and were praised for it" is a nice piece of rhetorical engineering. Monstrous arguments are often assembled from tiny units wh
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
Of course. "We quoted Mein Kampf and were praised for it" is a nice piece of rhetorical engineering.
Monstrous arguments are often assembled from tiny units which may be unobjectionable individually.
The implication that the journal editors failed to notice the evil taint of Nazism from short extracts is nonsense.
But the whole hoax is entirely political. The authors disapprove of what they call "Grievance Studies" and they wanted to call that out.
Which is fine as far as it goes, but as others have pointed out, it's not as if the SNR in other disciplines is perfect.
There's a huge amount of bullshit everywhere in academia - from theoretical physics to medicine to economics to computer science. [1]
Going Sokal proves nothing at all this point. We already know peer review doesn't work very well, because academia is now driven by financial and economic pressures more than it's driven by a noble quest for knowledge and wisdom.
Ironically the "grievance studies" people have done a better - albeit still slanted and ineffectual - job of pointing this out than the entire peer review system has.
[1] http://news.mit.edu/2015/how-three-mit-students-fooled-scientific-journals-0414 http://news.mit.edu/2015/how-three-mit-students-fooled-scien...