3 ms·
Why can’t the peer review system itself just evolve to embrace the full power of the internet? The main reasons these fraudulent strategies are at all effectiv
by choppaface 8y ago
Why can’t the peer review system itself just evolve to embrace the full power of the internet? The main reasons these fraudulent strategies are at all effective is because (1) the review process is private and slow and (2) studies aren’t independently reproduced as a part of review. The feedback loop is inherently too slow. To speed it up, one must fight the inertia of senior (tenured) faculty and major funding vehicles.
It’s laudible these researchers have invested so much in fighting fraud, but this post shows that the offenders will essentially face no negative consequences for fraud. The researchers worked very hard for hardly any return / justice.
Perhaps it’s worth re-inventing science. Open reviews. A network to connect labs that ensures findings are reproduced. We could even re-do much of basic, academic science in the interest of improving exposition and shedding antiquated formulations of theory.
What if, in the face of this fraud, we simply reject tradition wholesale? The only tradition should be an honest, reproducible study of Nature.
- CJefferson 8y agoMy problem is, just the "Full power of the internet" end up looking like Facebook, or Reddit, or Twitter, where the fastest and loudest repliers often end up having the biggest effect? Also, independently reproducing studies is super-important, but that going to take HUGE amounts of money, which someone is going to have to pay for. It was have to come from the top, most governments want to see new research, not reproductions, and scientists are guided by that direction.
- ausbah 8y ago"Full power of the internet" doesn't have to be like Facebook or Twitter. Maintaining some sort of decent moderation and having a wider "professional" culture (can't think of a better term here) can allow for some truly insightful interactions in the vein of HackerNews or some better known subreddits.