4 ms·
I agree with much of what you said including that costs are high due to government subsidies - I just think that the primary subsidy is keeping general interest
by mindslight 8y ago
I agree with much of what you said including that costs are high due to government subsidies - I just think that the primary subsidy is keeping general interest rates low. That mortgage interest tax deduction really just further reduces the the effective interest rate for home loans. The primary subsidy isn't even acknowledged as an explicit policy, but obscured by describing it as a mechanical application of a purported economic consensus.
I guess my point of disagreement is that since the low interest subsidy is basically turning any mildly dense area into a rent treadmill, then why isn't the goal to directly address that as the problem? The increasing financialization of most people's lives (pet insurance!!) seems like a much more pressing issue than trying to indirectly prop up rural economy.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I guess my point of disagreement is that since the low interest subsidy is basically turning any mildly dense area into a rent treadmill, then why isn't the goal to directly address that as the problem? Because nobody wants to touch it with a ten foot pole. There are basically two ways to get interest rates back up. The first is that you just do it, and nothing else. We've discovered that doing this at anything faster than glacially slow when people are as leveraged as they currently are causes the world to burn. If interest rates doubled over a short period of time, the thousands of dollars people are already paying in interest would also double, and eat all of their disposable income and then some, requiring them to borrow even more at the now-higher rates in order to make rent. Bankruptcies would follow. The higher interest rates would make it harder to get a huge mortgage at current housing prices, so housing prices would crash. People have borrowed money to invest in stocks because the return on stocks has been higher than the interest on money, and raising interest rates tends to be deflationary in general, so you raise interest rates fast and the stock market crashes. At the same time as the housing market. Nobody really wants this version. It's terrible. The alternative is that you raise interest rates against a backdrop of a series of pro-inflationary policies, that allow wages and the price of everything other than housing/healthcare/education to catch up and rebalance. And you need for people to pay down their debts so that interest rates can rise without bankrupting everyone, which means they need money to pay them with. But money comes from two places. One is debt -- banks create money when they make loans. But we can't use this one because the whole point is we need less of that. The other is the government creates it. They need to create enough money for people to pay off their debts with, which destroys it again. That would be trillions of dollars. And then enough on top of that for wages to catch up to housing prices. (A UBI would actually be a great way to deliver the money to people.) The banks would hate this with the fire of a thousand suns, because it would mean that the total amount of outstanding loans would fall significantly. In other words, their industry would shrink, by a lot. So those are your options. Lots and lots of bankruptcies and a huge economic crash, or printing trillions of dollars for people to pay their debts with. Either way the banks are stuffed -- and they're the ones with the largest influence on this kind of policy, so they're firmly in the "kick the can down the road" camp of leaving interest rates low.
- mindslight 8y agoThe summary is that we're addicted to debt, and I surely agree. But that means we should be even more vigilant to avoid advancing further in the ratchet! Why should individuals just ideologically accept this regime, rationalizing justifications to further speed up the debt treadmill as actually benefiting us somehow? We're just all supposed to accept living in a negative-sum container, where the financial class gradually takes title to more and more real property as interest compounds? Until the abstraction no longer holds, we get an economic collapse, and then we get to fight and eat one another while the fiction unwinds? I guess this is just the standard shape US politics take. The bankers buy both candidates and then the voters get to cheer for their preferred window dressing to win - more bread or more circuses. I'd personally rather get my tribe-kicks from watching professional sportsball, and keep my political head screwed on straight.