6 ms·
It appears that unfair and exclusionary zoning is squeezing Toronto's housing market: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/landlords-housing-advocates-hope-co
by jseliger 8y ago
It appears that unfair and exclusionary zoning is squeezing Toronto's housing market: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/landlords-housing-advocates-hope-council-loosens-arbitrary-rules-on-secondary-suites-1.4895814 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/landlords-housing-adv.... Looks like Toronto is, like most North American cities, is legally constricting the supply of housing, leading to higher prices: https://www.vox.com/cards/affordable-housing-explained/supply-side-of-affordable-housing-matters-most https://www.vox.com/cards/affordable-housing-explained/suppl....
The framing of the article's headline is bad.
- untog 8y agoBoth of those things can be correct. They can both contribute towards the housing squeeze.
- darawk 8y agoYes, but one of these things is increasing freedom, and the other is restricting it. In an ideal world, homeowners would be able to rent their place son AirBnB, and we'd have enough housing for everyone. The reason we can't live in that world is exclusionary zoning.
- maceurt 8y agoZoning is there for a reason. Airbnb does not follow zoning for commercial or hotel/motel regions and invades on residential zoning. The zoning system would work a lot better if Airbnb did not literally break the law. People buy residential apartments and houses then rent them out on Airbnb because that is a more profitable business model than leasing them to new tenants or selling them. If there needed to be more house zoning, then the price of prime real estate in a residential zoning area would be worth more to lease than rent out.
- darawk 8y ago> The zoning system would work a lot better if Airbnb did not literally break the law The zoning system was completely broken long before AirBnB showed up. Yes, Airbnb does exacerbate the already existing issues with zoning laws...but that's not an argument for eliminating Airbnb, it's an argument for eliminating or changing zoning laws.
- gamblor956 8y agoIn such an ideal world, the neighbors could then charge the Airbnb-owner for the value he derives from their presence making the AirBnb a desirable option (after all, AirBnB markets its services to people who want to "live like locals), and for any negative externalities imposed upon them by the AirBnb, such as increased traffic, liability risks, etc.
- darawk 8y agoYa, some kind of externality pricing there might be reasonable.
- throwaway2048 8y agoHey look over there, that guy is doing it too!
- manicdee 8y agoJust remember that "too few houses" is the same problem as "too many people." Why doesn't anyone suggest that there are too many people and that we need to control population growth to rates below zero?
- hughes 8y agoBecause people add value to a community... what would you suggest, blockading the routes into the city? Unless you have an idea for reversing the trend of urbanization, telling people where they can and can't live is going to be a tough sell.
- albemuth 8y agoEconomic growth, pensions...
- tareqak 8y agoCan you suggest ways to eliminate the "too many people" problem without restricting the freedoms and privileges of people? You can theoretically restrict the movement of people by decreasing immigration, or restricting local people to move into places with too many people. You can theoretically restrict having more children. Both of those restrictions have been hugely unpopular in places that have tried them. You cannot hold onto power in a democracy or democratic republic if you are sufficiently unpopular.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou don’t have a right to live wherever you want. This is economics at work (housing costs increase until reaching equilibrium with supply, with supply being constrained by geographic or governance limitations).
- chrischen 8y agoEconomics also dictates if that more people want to live in a place, more housing will be built. But intervention by law to prevent housing or slow it alters this.
- xiphias2 8y agoAlthough I haven't been to Toronto, there's an alternative to zoning: great public transportation. In Zurich I can get from any place to any other place easily because the tram/bus/train connections are always waiting for each other, and are almost never too early / late. People can use cars if they need it, but it shouldn't be the first choice generally.
- mykowebhn 8y agoI completely agree with you! And if it only were so easy! Toronto, and Canada, is very much like the US in terms of its reliance on the car to get around. Except in urban centers, and NYC, the first choice of transportation is almost always the car. This is not just a mindset. The lack of a proper transportation infrastructure and the sprawling nature of North American cities make it difficult to get around without a car. In fact, I would say urban sprawl and traffic are worse in Toronto than in most American cities (I'm originally from Toronto and I've lived in the US for more than two decades). And what about the surrounding regions, like York and Peel regions? I would say the prospects for an adequate public transportation infrastructure in the surrounding regions of Toronto are even worse, and the population in the surrounding suburbs rivals the population of Toronto proper.
- neurotrace 8y agoThat was not my experience with Toronto at all. I lived in the Liberty Village area over the summer and could very easily get around the city via public transit. The only time we drove was to get to get to the movie theater in Etobicoke. Eastern Toronto was extremely easy to get around.
- mykowebhn 8y agoYes, exactly. Liberty Village is very close to downtown Toronto. I wasn't commenting on the public transportation close to city centers.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoAre you saying that Zurich is a champion of affordable housing? Why is Zurich a model we should look to when trying to fix zoning? I'm not knocking their transit. I'm sure it's great. But you can have good transit, zoning, and affordable housing. See Berlin. And, yes, Berlin has it's problems, and I'm sure somewhere else is doing things even better. I'm just curious why Zurich is a model we should look to.
- kokokokoko 8y agoThen why are cities in the US where the population is currently declining also seeing significant increases in real estate pricing? Do you think it is at all interesting that housing pricing on the west coast of Canada and the US recently flattened out at the exact same time the economy slowed in China? Every single city in Canada and the US currently has this problem. Including Houston which has very permission zoning.
- hnnh44 8y agoActually, the flat lining investment from the Chinese in Vancouver and Toronto is partially due regulations put in place exactly for that purpose. Additional taxes on non-primary properties and vacant properties were aimed at curbing this.
- cycrutchfield 8y agoPrecisely this. Go to any city in the world where new housing is not artificially constricted by local governments and you will find that the effect of airbnb rentals on housing prices are minimal. I will not deny that the presence of airbnb rentals in a city can drive up the incremental cost of housing, but it is a proximate cause, not the root cause. The root cause is artificially constrained supply.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dmix 8y ago> The framing of the article's headline is bad. Vice's view of politics is always like a naive high school kid who hasn't ever had a real job or read a single book on economics. Which probably accurately describes their (largely freelance) 'journalists' or more accurately bloggers. Makes for good clickbait for their demographic though. In an ideal world they should really have stuck to fashion and culture (which their 'talent' is good at) and left the serious topics to people who have a strong grasp of the subjects. But that's boring and doesn't generate outrage on social media aka clicks -> ad views.
- Andre607 8y ago> Vice's view of politics is always like a naive high school kid who hasn't ever had a real job or read a single book on economics. Which probably accurately describes their (largely freelance) 'journalists' or more accurately bloggers. > Makes for good clickbait for their demographic though. In an ideal world they should really have stuck to fashion and culture (which their 'talent' is good at) and left the serious topics to people who have a strong grasp of the subjects. But that's boring and doesn't generate outrage on social media aka clicks -> ad views. The author of this piece worked at Bloomberg and CBC prior to her position as the Economics & Money editor at Vice. "But that's boring and doesn't generate outrage".
- dmix 8y agoWhich part of that discredits what I said about the quality of content at Vice news? Her 18 years working as a “fill in“ news anchor/talking head? In between a short stint as PR pusher a bitcoin advocacy company in Toronto before earning the title as ‘editor’ of the Finance section of Vice? Even if she’s somehow an exception to the rule at Vice as the editor, aka top tier in her category, she’d be a rarity. But looking at her previous output (only a few as she’s a recent hire) there are quite a few that fit into the clickbait vs signal ratio pandering to an ideological niche. That’s fine if that’s your thing but I put higher standards on the HN front page.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoToronto is a sea of construction cranes[1], so it's not certain that zoning is the issue. Sure if you want a single detached house you have to be a millionaire, but the supply of multi-unit dwellings is increasing quite quickly. 1: https://www.blogto.com/city/2018/08/toronto-has-highest-number-construction-cranes-north-america/ https://www.blogto.com/city/2018/08/toronto-has-highest-numb...